The lack of transparency about how these decisions are made has allowed a dangerous narrative to prevail: that the system is biased against fathers. Next year is the 20th anniversary of the formation of Fathers 4 Justice, a guerilla campaign perhaps best remembered for flourbombing Tony Blair at Prime Minister’s Questions. It has become progressively nastier since then – including a “crummy mummy” campaign singling out famous women for criticism.
Fathers 4 Justice demand the law enshrines a presumption of 50-50 contact. Their claims of court bias against men have gained broad traction in the debate around the subject, despite evidence to the contrary: a review of published court decisions found that they promote as much contact as possible with fathers, even in cases of proven domestic violence. A 2011 review of family law drew on evidence from Australia, where a legal presumption of shared parenting has been associated with poorer emotional outcomes for children. It concluded that there should be no legal change that “might risk creating a parental ‘right’ to any particular amount of time with a child” as it would undermine the principle that a child’s welfare is paramount. This did not stop the government introducing a garbled reform in 2014 that told courts to presume that, unless shown to the contrary, a parent’s involvement in their child’s life will always be to the child’s benefit.
But there is growing evidence to suggest women who have suffered domestic abuse and are worried for their children’s safety face an uphill battle to be taken seriously. Some judges have no understanding of domestic abuse – as highlighted in an excoriating high court ruling that overturned a finding by a senior male judge that it wasn’t rape “because she didn’t fight back”. That hasn’t stopped the judge involved continuing to preside over family court cases involving domestic abuse allegations and making a similar ruling in another case.
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
replies: