It's fiberglass, not vermiculite, so less likely to be asbestos contaminated. Though I didn't specifically test it.
I took out about 30 square feet of the stuff before deciding I didn't want to do that anymore.
It's clean, no dead stuff or mouse droppings, so I don't feel bad about leaving it in. It's easily compressible, old crappy stuff.
It's an 8 inch joist, so I squished some 10 inch unfaced batting on top of it, pressing the old stuff flat.
You can see the difference in temp on the ceiling:



