you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 6 points 2 hours ago (1 child)

I used to like HP when it was actively being released. Then I read more fantasy series and it showed me just how not good it is, JK's transphobia and bigotry aside. Then as I got older, the obvious racism like naming the Asian character 'Cho Chang' was on my radar. Young me didn't think anything about it at the time, older me saw it for what it is.

It's too bad that a better author didn't write the series. There's certainly potential in the universe for something great, but she didn't have the writing chops for it. If someone like Sanderson wrote it, there would be at least a dozen more books, the magic system would be better fleshed out, and the whole plot would have been properly developed and oddly disjointed much of the time.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 22 minutes ago

    I was older when HP first came out (old enough that I mostly associate those letters with Hewlett-Packard), so I recognized it as trash writing as soon as I laid eyes on it.

    It had one redeeming quality that effectively neutralized any complaint about JKR's shitty writing, it got young kids reading.

    It was pretty crazy to watch at the time. A bunch of kids around the age of the protagonists, who hadn't been reading at all, suddenly started reading. They read every book multiple times and eagerly looked for the next release. People who cared about literacy we gobsmacked.

    Once the movies came out, it was all over. A bunch of kids watched the movies instead of reading the books. Now they don't really motivate literacy; they're just shitty stories.

  • source
  • parent