MAGA failed because it didn’t go far enough, right-wing extremists say—and following devastating midterm losses, they see an opportunity to take over.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) (1 child)

If you aren't worried about lack of appeal to moderates, you could just go make a new party.

The reason that that approach won't work is because you won't appeal to moderates.

If you take over the Republican Party, you have the same problem. Moderates leave for the Democratic Party.

The American electoral system will intrinsically tend towards two big-tent parties that compete for and need to appeal to the center. If you cede the center, you won't meet with electoral success. If you maintain a grip on a party's mechanisms and force it away from the center, eventually a new Big Two Party will emerge, from fragments of your party and from some voters that it will pull off the other Big Two Party, and your once-Big-Two party will be relegated to a minor party.

You can be a far-right faction in a Big Two party and get a limited amount of your agenda in. But you can't take the party to the far right and also have electoral success.

We have the Constitution Party now. That's far right. It also doesn't meet with electoral success, because it can't appeal to the center.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment