you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 9 points 15 hours ago*

chess already doesn't have a traditional split of women's and men's categories, it has a split of women's and open. the reason behind it is that women are so underrepresented that even though there is no biological disadvantage to speak of, the trailing upper edge of the bell curve would leave so few of them in high tiers such as grandmaster and international master that they made women's grandmaster and women's international master titles to increase their representation. but nothing bars a woman from competing in open championships and acquiring open titles too. Judit Polgar, for example, is a GM, not a WGM.

imo it's indefensible with this justification not to include trans women. there are even fewer trans women in chess than cis women, so logically, they should be more protected and elevated, not less. and even if fide won't make a full-on trans women category (which they shouldn't for unrelated reasons), they already have a track record of letting people from the more exclusive category compete in the more inclusive one. there is zero mathematical reason to worry about including trans women in women's chess, and there are no arguments for trans exclusion that are in any way consistent with their treatment of cis women.

  • source
  • parent