Alaska voters have rejected the latest attempt to repeal the state’s system of open primaries and ranked choice voting in general elections.

The ballot measure, decided as part of the Nov. 3 election, marked the second time in two years that voters have rejected attempts to overturn the system and revert to partisan primaries and to general elections in which just one candidate can be selected. The measure also would have repealed some campaign disclosure rules.

Voters in 2020 narrowly adopted the new system, which was used for the first time in 2022. Supporters of open primaries and ranked voting say it gives voters more choices and forces candidates to build a broader coalition of support. They also say it’s had a moderating effect on the state Legislature, which has been governed under bipartisan coalitions in recent years.

Opponents, including Donald Trump, say it’s confusing. He has railed against the system for years. Elon Musk was among the donors trying to the repeal effort.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 2 days ago* (last edited 2 days ago) (6 children)

Except it doesn't at all.

All Ordinal voting systems trend towards two party dominance. Because all Ordinal voting systems have some degree of spoiler effect.

The Marquis de Condorcet wrote about the mathematical flaws of a system identical to Ranked Choice back in 1785. His chief complaint was that it could not reliably elect the pair-wise winner, that is, the person who would win a one on one election against every other candidate. Condorcet found that the more candidates that you add, the less likely you'll see the pair-wise winner be elected.

There is hope, Cardinal voting systems exist, and tend to work better the more candidates you have (to a point).

STAR was designed back in 2014. It's good.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 1 day ago (5 children)

    In only half jest, I think if you know enough about voting systems to have an opinion on voting systems, and especially if you can cite Condorcet, you're ineligible to comment on best voting system.

    Remember, taking horse dewormer as an antiviral unironically caught on; in 2026 a real chunk of the voting populace thinks Trump is smart, and fucking measles is back. I once had an elementary school teacher ask me if crickets were baby bats, and I've heard more than once an adult "correct" a child that invertebrates weren't animals.

    You need, if not the buy-in, at least not the skepticism of action of a voting system from these people.

    People get "1,2,3". You can explain it because it's not very different than a To-Do list.

    Anything more complicated than that is too complicated unless they've already been living with IRV enough to internalize it (and maybe not even then). STAR voting? Giving points away? Totals don't just fail to add up evenly across the board but swing largely? Instant no-go.

    It's like Linux folks that can't realize the most complicated action in an OS to get 99.999% of things running under default settings is "double click the icon".

    Or, if you prefer, because there's an XKCD for everything: https://xkcd.com/2501/

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 19 hours ago (4 children)

    How is rating each candidate on a scale of 0-5 harder than ranking them in some arbitrary order?

    Rankings lead to worse results than ratings, and are just less satisfying to use. What if you like two candidates the same? Better chose one over the other and then hope that other people in your situation ranked the two in the same order, otherwise one of the two will act as a spoiler for the other. Arrow's Impossibility Theorem clearly says that all ranked voting methods will have a spoiler candidate, so you'll run face first into that.

    But rated systems do not have a spoiler effect, if you're using STAR, you rate each candidate independently of each other. The system doesn't care if you like A more than B, or like them the same, it just cares what the total rating for each candidate is. With the added step of looking at the top two candidates and seeing which one was rated higher on each ballot.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 16 hours ago (3 children)

    How is rating each candidate on a scale of 0-5 harder than ranking them in some arbitrary order?

    Because, as I said, ratings give wildly divergent sums.

    While not every round of IRV gives exactly equal sums because of exhaustion, generally they're close. Eyeballing the sum of multiple six digit values doesn't obviously fail.

    This isn't true for ratings, by design. This means it doesn't pass the underinformed vibe check, which is the second biggest requirement in a voting system behind "not cheating" (because to them it vibes as cheating, so to them it fails the cardinal rule).

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 15 hours ago (2 children)

    It doesn't matter if your uniformed vibe check passes, because IRV has serious problems.

    It's like looking at a house built out of rotted timber found in the woods and thinking, sure, the outside looks good, it must be good. That other house with it's fancy modern design sure doesn't look a falling down log cabin, so it must not be a good house.

    IRV has been shown to reinforce two party dominance via application of the spoiler effect. It has had multiple real world elections where the pair-wise loser was elected because of a quirk that's unique to IRV.

    STAR on the other hand has been designed by actual experts, I know people don't seem to trust those anymore, but then people are also dying from measles again. I guess we're just choosing the absolute worst option on principle these days.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 15 hours ago (1 child)

    IRV is better than plain voting. No one claims perfect.

    Better is inherently worthwhile, because incremental improvement gets shit done. Purity testing just perpetuates bad outcomes for longer.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment