but CC’s meme is very very much modern lib arguments i18nly
wut
It's literally not tho
Like CC's meme is deliberately arguing that the liberal perspective, that 'immigration is acceptable because it makes money', is wrong and closer in spirit to the fascists and bourgeois conservatives they loudly claim to hate.
This is not a lib argument. It's a leftist argument. It's part of the "leftist memes" cultural meme, i.e. presenting longer tracts of analysis in a meme format. It deliberately the subverts the "image macro" format. The length is supposed to be part of the joke.
Again, I actually quite like your version, since it concretely states your beliefs and curtly argues why. Love it! Both versions are good pieces of agitprop for different audiences, both of whom I want to bring into our movement.