you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 10 points 6 hours ago (2 children)

Power corrupts

Magical thinking helps no one. Power is not a magic force that corrupts all who touch it, this isn't Lord of the Rings. It is a social relation that allows people to more effectively work in their interests. The issue is that society in much of the world thus far has been structured such that a minority class, be they the landlords and aristocracy of feudalism or the bourgeoisie of capitalism, hold an effective monopoly. They use this monopoly to extract surplus and protect their property. The solution is not to wish away power, but to seize it and democratize it, transforming it from a tool of class exploitation into an instrument of social administration.

subjecting a healthy adult to anyone other than themselves is always harm.

By your logic, nuclear power station workers being subject to the safety team is truly harmful. An operating room being subject to a chief surgeon is another great harm.

Or is it possible that hierarchy is a useful social relation that has been reproduced across geography, centuries, and even species for a reason?

In nature, coordinated structures emerge because they solve material problems of survival and resource management. In human society, as the division of labor grows more complex, large scale production physically demands coordination, discipline, and unified direction. A factory, a railway network, or a hospital cannot run on pure consensus without collapsing.

The goal should not be to abolish all authority, which would mean abolishing industry and modern society itself. The goal should be to abolish class authority. End the subjection of people to people as exploiters, and replace it with the rational, democratic administration of things and the technical direction of production.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [+] -7 points 5 hours ago (1 child)

    Your confusing hierarchy and authority, dont worry i also still mix them up sometimes.

    Trusting and following a leader is not the same as being subjected to an authority.

    If a chief is wrong then the assistants should be free to resist. They only follow as long as they agree with the direction.

    About abolishing major parts of modern industry and society. uhm in my wildest dreams maybe. But realistically we are better of evolving things slowly

    There is no magic involved in “power corrupts”, its just a way to reference the mental illnesses that emerge in people when leadership stops being contested.

    But i know the community i am in, i am not really here to fight tankies, that just results in stale mate. in many ways we overlap and fight the same abstracted evils really as i welcome the resistancd against the usa. My comments are intended for other inspiring anarchists who dont know what tankies are about yet frequently end up confused when sharing opinions that they tought where aligned with the opinions expessed in the content featured on ml. Because really, many memes here are delighfully refreshing for anti-nationalists.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 9 points 5 hours ago

    I am not confusing hierarchy and authority. If binding decisions are being made and enforced, then authority exists. Whether someone "agrees" with the direction is irrelevant to the material reality of the situation. If a janitor believes they have a better idea for how to run the core of a nuclear reactor, they still should not be permitted to touch it. Authority in production is simply the enforcement of the binding decisions required to keep complex systems functioning.

    You casually suggest abolishing major parts of modern industry, even if "slowly." This is nothing but a reactionary fantasy. Dismantling complex, large-scale production is deeply ableist. Sick and disabled people often rely on the highly coordinated, global production of pharmaceuticals, medical equipment, and life-sustaining infrastructure. Wishing this away privileges the temporarily able-bodied and ignores the material basis of human survival.

    Furthermore, reducing class power to "mental illness" is both idealist and ableist. Capitalists and landlords do not exploit the working class because they are individually unwell. They do so because the material structure of their class position demands it. They act in their objective class interest to preserve property relations and extract surplus. Masking systemic, material exploitation as individual pathology prevents any real understanding of how society functions.

    You claim your comments are meant for "inspiring" anarchists who get confused by Marxist-Leninist content. But these are not fresh insights. They are recycled, long-debunked misunderstandings and misappropriations of political concepts. Framing idealist confusion as inspiration will only mislead people who are genuinely seeking a materialist path to oppose imperialism and capitalism.

  • source
  • parent