VRChat is currently weathering a sizable backlash among users due to a controversial decision to not label AI-generated content.

The News

VRChat released a survey earlier this month asking users whether the social VR platform should in some way label AI-generated content as a way to fight back against low-quality slop.

The survey in question polled over 21,000 users. While results are no longer viewable online, Japanese outlet Automaton reports that around 95% of survey responders indicated they wanted VRChat to add an AI-generated content label, which would simplify filtering out AI content.

In a statement last week, the studio announced it won’t be implementing the change, maintaining the move may cause more harm than good:

“We’re not adding an ‘AI-generated’ label or AI filters. While we think some creators would honestly label their content, we think others would try to pass off generative or assisted work as completely authored by hand,” VRChat says. “Likewise, we could see this creating ‘sleuthing’ behavior, where folks would attempt to sniff out ‘AI’ content or might harass other creators, even if they are genuinely not using any AI tools in their workflow. We think this potentially creates negative behavior spirals we don’t want to encourage.”

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 5 points 6 days ago

As someone who spends a lot of time on VRChat, the important context this artical leaves out is the fact that while 95% of survey respondants said they'd like some kind of AI Labeling, there wasn't really any concensus for what that labeling should include or what it should look like. Should a VRChat world be labeled as an AI world if it just has some instructional text that was AI translated from Japanese to English? If AI textures were used? What if textures were AI upscaled, but not completely AI generated?

VRChat's response to the situation felt actually like a very reasonably nuanced take and I'd encourage people to read it straight from the source rather than just how some news aticle interprets it.

The original post from VRChat can be found at: https://ask.vrchat.com/t/where-were-landing-on-ai-in-vrchat/49178

  • source