Yeah you got that right - the whole driving oneself nuts with consumer tire gauges. For all I know my tires could be totally fine and I’m just consistently not using the same gauge twice 🤪 I only realized after a comment here and then watching a Project Farm video where he tested like 10 different gauges and a whole bunch of them were wildly off (by more than 5psi).
My gauge arrives in a couple days so we shall see. Thanks for the advice!
Edit: ya this was it. I’m dumb and my tires are good.