Yesterday while walking my dog i was practicing my Finnish, as one does. Specifically i was counting, something i had not practiced in a while. While counting in the -teens, i realized -toista reminded me of Toinen. I looked it up today, and sure enough they are the same root.
So 15, viisitoista appears to literally mean, 5 again, or 5 the second.
-toista
Etymology
From the partitive singular toista of toinen (“second”), by ellipsis of the phrase toista kymmentä (literally “of the second decade”), referring to the second ten of numbers (11–19). yksitoista, for example, originally was yksi toista kymmentä (literally “one of/into the second decade”), as the first "decade" (first ten numbers) were already counted. This system used to be used more widely, but is now only used for 11 to 19, possibly by influence from the Germanic languages where those numerals too get special names, while numbers beyond 19 are more formulaic.