Officially old and turned 60 recently, I have investment income outside Super (no formal job) so I contribute voluntary concessional contributions in order to claim a tax deduction on that income earned outside Super.

I could now convert that accumulation account to a pension account and drawdown say $30k per annum tax free and recontribute it to a new accumulation account to claim said $30k as a tax deduction. Gives me more income outside super (cirrently being used to make $30k concessional deductions) to spend on cocaine and hookers or waste it I guess. (I'm so old I remember the George Burns joke, albeit I have mangled it).

Few notes on what I've found out: 4% min draw down needed from age 60-65, 5% min after that and must have an honest to goodness job after 67 in order to have an accumulation account.

Most people seem to use that strategy to avoid super inheritance tax, not sure how that works for that situation, have no dependents anyway and have no insurance in Super becase of that. Have spoken to an advisor at ART Super about the mechanics of it all and will speak to my accountant.

Looking for a sanity check not financual advice per se.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 9 months ago (1 child)

Sorry, if I'm misunderstanding, would you be drawing down income that has been in super, and already been taxed 15% (not completely tax free, just already paid, so no further tax),only to then put it back into super and be taxed 15% on it again to then claim it as a deduction from other income? So you'd pay 4500 more for the plan. Effectively this income has been taxed at 30% overall, so missing out on the super concession, with the intention of reducing tax on other investments, yes?

How much will you save? What's your effective tax rate on the top 30k of your other income?

I don't see how it gives you more income outside super, as you said. Your income should remain the same. Your tax bill may change. So more money in your pocket, at the expense of compind interest etc. Then my question becomes what is your goal? Do you want more cash on hand? What will you do with the funds. If you plan to spend it then it may be worth it. You might have a bit extra after accountant fees and account fees but your retirement egg will still have that required draw down which could go against future plans. Markets are volatile at the moment. So could go either way with how that pans out.

I believe there are some rules around moving funds with the express purpose of avoiding tax and this would seem to be a clear example of it, so it could come back to bite you.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 2 points 9 months ago

    How much will you save? What's your effective tax rate on the top 30k of your other income?

    30%... So I'll contribute $30k from money that will be taxed at 30% (earnings outside super) and claim that as a deduction, I don't work per se, have been retired since I was 40 and live off investment income that's earned outside of super. I can't use this strategy past age 67, am now 60 or whwn my earnings outside Super drop so low my tax rate falls to 15% as it then makes no sense.

    https://www.ato.gov.au/forms-and-instructions/superannuation-personal-contributions-notice-of-intent-to-claim-or-vary-a-deduction

    reducing the 30% tax paid on that $30k to 15% (tax rate inside super) a $4500 tax saving per annum.

    I don't see how it gives you more income outside super, as you said.

    By making up the $30k of income that I just contributed from my outside of super earnings, from tax free (at the point of withdrawal) drawdown on the super pension account. Until now I had been contributing the $30k reducing my spendong money.

    I believe there are some rules around moving funds with the express purpose of avoiding tax and this would seem to be a clear example of it, so it could come back to bite you.

    No it isn't, you seem to be conflating tax avoidance with tax minimisation if I read thay correctly., apologies if I misunderstand. Super re-contribition is oft used, see below.

    https://www.superguide.com.au/super-booster/super-re-contribution-strategy

    https://www.canstar.com.au/superannuation/super-recontribution-strategy/

    I also make non concessional contributions. At a drawdown of $30k p.a my income pension capital should still increase in value from earnings within Super, short a Trump led world meltdown.

  • source
  • parent