Read up on the nazi occupation of Europe, in many places like the Netherlands where people engaged in peaceful protest after surrender, while the Dutch government started to work with the nazis. Hence they were able to do all their bullshit, such as mass deportations. There's multiple spaces in the Netherlands that are basically mass graves or memorials because we tried to reason with fucking nazis.

But in other places such as Denmark, people resisted and fought back together with government support despite the occupation, because of this the nazis weren't able to do most of their shit. Your country is currently infested with nazis who are deporting your people, fight them, don't reason with them. Sabotage them, refuse them service, boycott companies that provide them with services, make their lives hell, don't let them shop in your stores, walk on your streets or do anything, it's the only option.

Renee wouldn't have to pull a gun, so long as some observers and protesters are carrying. This is because there is an implication: "If you harm us, we will do the same to you." It would go BOTH ways.

Problem is, ICE doesn't have consequences of any kind to keep them from committing violence. They get the satisfaction of hurting people, without paying a price for it.

The other thing that's horrible but meaningful to absorb is that: We are at war with ICE. It's not "escalation towards war", this slow motion of opinions is the war.

If you imagine the many thousands of people who died for our freedoms in World War 2, it becomes impossible to fathom, both the tragic loss, and the bravery of those volunteering to go. We're instead fighting along ideology lines, rather than an actual frontline.

Point being, choosing to risk one's self to announce ICE's presence and protest their actions is a similar form of bravery, and it does have an impact. Everyone choosing to tackle that challenge should be aware of the nonzero chance their actions may result in being a victim of violence or even death. If you can look to the bravery of old war veterans, and accept the comparably low, but still present, level of risk from nonviolent protest, it becomes easier to accept it as a path forward; especially since we can unfortunately see that a decade of fighting Nazi Germany did not utterly destroy the Nazi party.

Right, she didn’t and we get outrage and a chance.

No, all you get is outrage. And dead protesters are dead protesters, peaceful or not.