In b4 someone calls me a tankie

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 0 points 11 months ago (3 children)

There are virtually zero actually communist countries in the world. That is factually true.

I'm not a marxist, but this point doesn't make sense to me. "Communist countries" aren't called that because they have somehow managed to achieve a communist society (which would be impossible to exist in a capitalist world), but because they are ruled by a governent that is ruled by a group/party which is (or at the very least claims to be) ideologically communist..

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 11 months ago* (2 children)

    No, they are not ideologically communist. A ruling party is by definition not communist. They are diometrically opposed.

    Even having an identifiable "owning class", let alone anything close to a "ruling class" is also definitionally not communist.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 6 points 11 months ago

    No, they are not ideologically communist. A ruling party is by definition not communist. They are diometrically opposed.

    To clarify, 'ideologically communist' means being part of a movement aiming to build a 'communist society' (communist mode of production, classless, moneyless, etc.). It makes sense for someone to call themselves a communist despite owning money, being in a social class, living under a state. In fact, a member of the bourgeoisie can be a communist, so long as they are actually helping to build the communist movement - it just means they're a class traitor. A communist who is part of the ruling class is a paradox, not a contradiction.

    The communist movement does not imply prefiguration, where the movement has to immediately begin reflecting their ideal society - anarchist tendencies tend to prefer prefiguration as a transitional method, while Leninist tendencies tend to see overemphasis on it as utopian and reckless, favoring vanguardism, that ruling party you mentioned.

    I see no reason why vanguardism contradicts the communist movement. The ideologically-driven ruling party aims to build a surrounding environment which will gradually abolish itself ('withering away of the state'). This is a paradox, but not a contradiction. Their ruling party aims to be temporary, seen as a necessary step to make it possible to build that communist society.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 11 months ago

    No, they are not ideologically communist. A ruling party is by definition not communist. They are diometrically opposed.

    Being ideologically communist simply means that you believe the ideal society is a communist society. Theoretically, you could be the king of britain and still be a communist.

    I'm sure there are many people who are members of communist parties who are not actual communists, but there are some true believers who think they are working towards a communist society in the far future by building up state power in order to "compete" with capitalist/imperialist forces.

    Again, I doubt their methods will work. I don't think you can work towards a stateless society by strenghtening the state. But I'm not gonna deny their ideals because I don't like their approach.

  • source
  • parent