On reddit there's an interesting theory, that it's actually purified dehydrated brains the Others are drinking.
Tap for spoiler
It was related to Carol's comment about the substance having a Ph of 7.1. Brains having a a Ph of 7.2.
This kind of makes it an interesting twist, as it means that this is effectively a zombie flick. "... braaaaaaains"
It also opens up some speculation that "the cure" is to simply "stop drinking the brain juice" and they'll lose their ability to join the hive.
Tap for spoiler
However, given the strong reaction the Others had when Carol tried to separate one of their people... it won't be easy.