[–] 2 points 1 month ago

The fact that everyone despises Adobe lately (last few years?) for their extremely anti consumer practices makes this case so much more difficult to judge.

On one hand, it is a blatant steal of an intellectual property. Not the code, but the UI, the philosophy behind the programs, with zero creativity added. On the other hand, fuck Adobe.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 1 month ago

    What is being self-hosting? I haven’t seen MPI used outside of software running on a compute cluster.

    One of the points of the cluster was to celebrate Apple’s founding, and the bundled MPI library just let them run an existing workload without switching the OS to Linux.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 57 points 1 month ago* (5 children)

    Y'all are missing the bigger picture here. This brings up the question of ai and intellectual property and throws the ball into adobe's court to set their army of lawyers on figuiring out a no-win solution for themselves.

    • If they do nothing, a working clone normalizes copying their product's behavior and UI. Copyright covers that thinly anyway (the First Circuit in Lotus v. Borland treated a command menu hierarchy as an unprotectable method of operation). Trademarks need policing!! (And they suck)
    • If they go after it, they have to argue in court that AI output built from public material is infringing or derivative. That's the precedent the AI industry wants to avoid, and it cuts against Adobe's own Firefly pitch. Imagine what that means for "art" made with an LLM
    • If the clone's code is mostly AI-written, its copyrightability is shaky (Copyright Office, Thaler). But that cuts both ways: Adobe can't claim "you stole our code" without proving actual copied code. Which bites into OpenAI, Anthropic, Google's claims that they haven't stolen anything.

    Edit: Sorry I should've used Super Intelligence, I don't want to be the enemy. /s

  • source
  • [–] 10 points 1 month ago* (1 child)

    I have the whole suite of apps installed as a Flatpak. The Photoshop clone is the fastest one to implement features, but the whole suite is moving really fast. Looking at the commits and features shipped, I haven't seen anything like this. It looks very well organized.

    I have been using Adobe Photoshop, Illustrator and InDesign professionally for ~30 years. These Craft apps are freaking amazing, they open in the blink of an eye and open multi-gb files just as fast. Working with these big files is also instantaneous.

    I have done my own calculations, and what they say is true, the Suite will reach beta status by mid-late October depending on the app. But the suite in general will be ready with more features than what a basic-intermediate user would want.

    I think what will make or break the Suite is if they go with local AI or not for Neural filters and generative fill. The community might turn on them if they don't.

    But technically speaking It's truly an amazing feat.

    These are my own projections, so it's not official:

    Repo Ready today Hours to beta Beta (central) Range
    vectorcraft 62% 170–270 Oct 13 Oct 12–15
    lightcraft 61% 340–600 Oct 15 Oct 13–19
    photocraft 45% 1,100–1,800 Oct 22 Oct 17–31
    effectcraft 45% 350–620 Oct 22 Oct 17 – Nov 1
    filmcraft 56% 400–700 Oct 22 Oct 17 – Nov 1
    printcraft 49% 400–700 Oct 22 Oct 16–31
    designcraft 47% 435–775 Nov 26 Nov 3 – Jan 4
  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 1 month ago

    This is so cool. The MacMini really is a great, little form factor.

    Interesting decision to take off the bottom of the case. I wonder if that was for cool or hardware access.

  • source
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›