[–] 1 point 3 months ago (1 child)

I personally disagree with the assertion that simulation is unnecessary because dice exist. Crunch and randomization work differently, and serve different purposes in a design. Crunch is good for accounting for the factors that are known, predictable, or obviously true in the fiction. Randomization, by contrast, is good for things not easily known or tracked, or that one could never guess would be true in the moment.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 3 months ago* (last edited 3 months ago) (2 children)

    I don’t necessarily want to jettison this level of crunch, as I think it’s integral to the tone the system is designed around, but fuck me if it isn’t a lot to keep track of

    Allow me to disagree with the highlighted statement. A mistake old school game designers used to make is to try and reflect every fluff detail in the rules. You don't have to differentiate an assault rifle in full auto from an SMG and in most cases, even an HMG. If you go down this route, you will need to account environmental factors, fatigue, time of day... which are also big influencers. But we don't, because that's what randomizers are for. Just bundle the difference in the randomizers.

    You'll say, correctly, "getting hit by a .50 cal is a world of difference compared to a 9mm". That's true. That's fiction and setting, though. It doesn't have to be reflected in the rules of simulating shooting the things in a game.

    My advice would be to do exactly what you proposed not to: chuck the entire system. Use a generic system instead. Whatever you're most familiar with: Cortex, Savage Worlds, Fate, GURPS...

    What is your story about? If it is about handling the gear, then perhaps (perhaps!) keep the OG system. If it's about anything else - a shared overarching plot you'll write with the players; about how the characters react and evolve to their surroundings; about interpersonal drama; base building, you name it - use a different system.

    Of the ones I listed, Savage Worlds is easily reskinned, Fate is easily tweaked, Cortex is a toolbox to get your game moving fast just the way you want it to feel, and GURPS probably already has a module for you to use. If you want to bounce ideas with other people adapting to Fate and Cortex, they both have very active Discord communities (I know, information silo, but that's where the authors hang out). Good luck!

    P.S.: I just remembered Cepheus (a Traveller retrocolone) has the acclaimed Modern War from Zozer Games. I have played their Hostile (Alien universe RPG) and the ruleset is essentially the same. There is some crunch, but easier than D20: https://www.zozergames.com/modern-war.html

    It looks like it and Delta Green lead sales on military RPGs: https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/browse?genre=320-military

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 3 months ago (2 children)

    First line becomes the title, so keep that in mind. Your title looks atrociously clickbaity now ("Bundle of Holding are currently not offering one, not offering two, not even offering three"), which might explain the downvote I see.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 3 months ago (1 child)

    Short: yes, it would sell. Do it!

    Long: This is the format found in the then very popular "Volo's guide to..." AD&D sourcebooks. They were prefaced and annotated here and there by Elminster, the scholar mage extraordinaire of the setting. The idea was that this Marco Volo character documented tales of places, creatures, magicks, etc. not only without rigor, but prone to exaggerations, inaccuracies, and outright fabrications. Like fake travelogues of the 19th century, just looking for a quick buck from naive readers.

    It was popular for a few reasons:

    • very well written, fun to read
    • delicious, flavorful prose that added color to the world along with data
    • establishes an unreliable narrator, which encouraged GM's to deviate freely from written lore
  • source
  • [–] 1 point 3 months ago (1 child)

    Yes, I get it. For that I loved playing FitD. Our table does not like playbooks/classes and I like pool-less rolls with different dice but the rest was working really well.
    The second example you gave reminds me of how Neon City Overdrive (I think it's reskinned City of Mist?) and Technoir work

    So clearly those ideas have been seeping through to western systems too. But maybe, since you've apparently found the source of this so-called "narrative" approach, in your explorations you have found some other interesting ideas? I don't mean full-blown translations, rather a walkthrough of sorts

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 3 months ago

    in this system, firing a ranged weapon interacts with almost every mechanic in the game

    Well. In that case, I would do the opposite. Have everything BUT combat in the first few games. So you build a foundation to then put the firing a weapon on top of it

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 3 months ago*

    I've run customized DnD for a few years. It can be a lot of fun if you're the type of person who enjoys creating and balancing mods for their games. Eventually, I got bored of the limitations of the system, and 5.5e killed my interest altogether.
    After a few attempts at changing game system, I simply quit the campaign and told my group why.

    Sometimes people just need a gentle push. I tried "Let's play something else! No? Okay, DnD it is" for years and it didn't work, so I told them, without half measures, I would not play DnD anymore.
    They still play DnD with other friends of theirs, but now they are willing to make an honest attempt at trying other stuff, too.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 months ago (2 children)

    Regarding jRPG, I managed to translate a few already, nothing professional, and my Japanese isn’t yet there (something close to an A2 hare), but the focus on the drama before the mechanics creates some difernete mind model, you focus on “what you do” instead of which “spell you have”

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 months ago (1 child)

    Ohhh you have used a “reader mode” or something similar. This is invisible ink for the crawlers that ignore my “do not scrape this page” and still crawl in it.

    Im still figuring out a better way to make the invisible ink not visible on the reader mode, but yet exists for the crawler.

    sorry for that.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 1 point 3 months ago (1 child)

    I wish I could make my players to go with Fabula Última!

    But for then, it’s DnD, luckily for me I was able to make then use my “custom rules” that already adds some of the Fabula Ultima details on the game. Yet far from the main concepts

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 months ago (1 child)

    Is SR3, ShadowRun 3rd edition? I've never played, beyond the tutorial of the revival cRPG from years ago, but I recall being similarly aghast at the plethora of options in the character creator. It's a shame, because the premise is awfully enticing. Ah well, as someone else in here mentioned, it seems like learning new systems has some inertia to it. The more you learn, the easier it is to learn more, since there only so many ways to roll a die lol. Maybe Shadowrun can be a project for future me.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 months ago (1 child)

    Your points about getting a baseline understanding of the flow and adding crunch in as GM and players get comfortable is well taken. My initial strategy was to focus on only one mechanic (in this case, firing a ranged weapon), but to know that mechanic absolutely front to back. However, in this system, firing a ranged weapon interacts with almost every mechanic in the game, so I was still trying to drink from the firehose. Thank you for taking the time and sharing your input.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 3 months ago* (5 children)

    Ryuutama, for example, is literally called “the Japanese Hayao Miyazaki RPG.” It’s about travel, exploration, and gentle adventure. The mechanics reinforce that with weather systems, caravan management, and a focus on journey over destination.

    (...)

    SRS (Standard RPG System) games in Japan take this even further. Instead of trying to model physics, they model drama. You don’t have “climbing skill”, you have I’m the agile thief with a heart of gold as a mechanical tag that pays off when it’s relevant.

    At this point I'd like to see someone walk us through a selected list of Japanese systems

    btw
    what's up with those "Important messages"?

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 3 months ago (2 children)

    It gets easier with each new system. After a while it becomes "ok, so it's approach to skills like in the other system and the armor rules from that other one". What I do when assessing a new one is:

    • how the basic mechanic works?
      • we build the roll only from PC or also consider gear?
      • how modifiers work? + to roll, step up dice, another dice, move TN?
      • what are the odds of success, failure and "bigger success" on three edges of of skill - lowest, middle, top
      • what does the bigger success mean mechanically?
      • are there re-rolls/pushing the roll? Does it change the odds or is only a re-roll
    • how leveling up works?
      • what is needed to level up?
      • how much does a level up change in the roll odds?
    • how does money work?
      abstract vs counting all the bills
    • is there anything exotic in the rest of the rules
      things that are there to convey the feel of the setting
      • contacts working like money
      • rules for gear getting used up
      • running out of ammo
      • meta currency
        is it a hard earned boon or "the spice must flow"?

    With crunchy systems I'd then forget about the more intricate half of the system, get the game on and try to have combats of varying size during first few sessions. Most of the time, if there's crunch in the system, it's mostly about combat.
    Write on players' sheets shortcuts what to roll on doing what. Like next to the gun name "shooting d6+d8".
    During first few games when you remember that there was some more crunch in the system but don't remember exactly, don't stop to look up. Ask a non-spotlighted player to search for it but "for now let's roll this and that against that" and keep going.
    Keep an eye out if they are getting into the crunch. If they won't follow you down the rabbit hole in a few (3-5. not less) games, it might be that either you get the rules etched in your brain or that level of crunch is just not for this table

    And on closing note, as far as I understand what T2k is, I would guess that getting their hands on an MG is not something common in the setting and the complexity of the rules for that are an outlier. I might be wrong, though

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 3 months ago

    If I wanna learn it, I usually have to be a player first.

    The few times I've had to be the GM it always comes off the cuff. My most hated thing is pausing a game to look up mundane rules about encumbrance or climbing or anything.

    Eventually you'll learn, at most just write down what you should look up later.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 3 months ago (2 children)

    Maybe it’s me that come from SR3 and think that anything not near that is simple 😅

    IIRC most of the gameplay loop for T2K is roll Two Dice, count your successes, assess what they do.

    I think that when played you mostly need that at least it was my experience in Mutant Year Zero

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 3 months ago

    A good post.

    I personally find DND unsatisfying for many reasons (little to no degree of success, static magic system that encourages hoarding, the primary defense is all or nothing avoidance, very coarse progression, some character concepts are simply not representable, etc)

    But what is even more annoying than that is when players respond with "but you can just change the rules!". I know! That's true of any pen and paper game! It's not some unique property of DND. But sometimes I don't want to do the work of designing a system, and I almost never want to play some stranger's pre-alpha homebrew.

  • source
  • [–] [S] 5 points 3 months ago (3 children)

    Could be I'm just dumb and unfamiliar with crunchier RPG systems, I'll freely allow for that, but man, I feel like you and I have a different definition of "simple" lol. Considering this is a flowchart for adjudicating a single Ranged Combat roll, to say nothing of any other mechanic in the game. Granted, this is particularly egregious, but it's also the main thing most characters will be doing in combat.

    I suppose the old adage holds true. How do you get to Carnegie Hall? Practice, practice, practice.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 months ago (1 child)

    Aye, I've been following their uploads and it has been helpful from a general observation perspective. I wish they were a little clearer about the rules they are navigating, but I recognize it's not a teaching cast either. I will say it's been illuminating how free-wheeling the Ref is with the NPC rules, which has helped me conceptualize the flow a bit better.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›