[–] 1 point 2 months ago

Okay, in the spirit of constructive criticism, here are some of my biggest problems with other VTTs:

  • I don't like the Quest Portal uses AI.
  • I wish Foundry had better anti AI clauses for their community marketplace.
  • I think Roll 20 haven't lived up to the (better) anti AI position they stated for their interim policy.

I'm not making a joke.

If you gutted the AI features from this project, I would very happily approach a "free as in beer" platform that has a special focus on bilingual accessibility. It's clear though that this platform is fundamentally integrated with AI. Therefore, I don't think it can ever address my biggest issues with other VTT platforms.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 1 point 3 months ago* (last edited 3 months ago)

    If this is their position, and I'm not convinced of this, then I understand them and what I can say is: don't use Dice Roost, not even for features that don't involve the use of AI, if they believe they're supporting exploitative multinationals. However, the discussion seemed to me to be going on a completely different path, not to mention those who simply wrote, "Fucking ew." And just so you know, Foundry, just to name one, has a bunch of plugins that use AI.

    I understand the comparison with the vegan dinner, but no one directly invited you. Meat-based dinners will always be around. I open a restaurant that 'also' advertises meat dishes (and not only), and vegans come to me in the comments to tell me I'm a 'murderer' or 'insensitive', for goodness sake, they're free to do so, but the discussion is dry and leads nowhere. It would be much more useful to start a discussion where they explain their reasons without offending the work of others and giving the opportunity to set up a serious and mature discussion table.

    I'd also like to add a thought of my own: this battle against AI seems like the latest fad. I'd like to know if the same people who are blaming AI for the new evil (without considering the benefits it brings to serious matters, not just D&D, such as curing rare diseases, genetic mapping, land mapping, preventing geological disasters, and many others) are the same people who avoid buying plastic bottles, don't buy the latest iPhone made in China from companies that exploit children, or only buy homemade clothes to avoid exploitation in third-world countries.

    I'm here to accept any negative criticism, but it must be constructive. It seems to me that there's a stance here for which people can't even provide valid reasons. No one has yet responded point by point to what I wrote.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 3 months ago* (1 child)

    @DiceRoost @bignose What they’re saying is they find the inclusion of some kind of LLM based AI system to be unethical. The manner in which the data was obtained for training LLMs, the environmental impacts of the AI data center build outs, and the way AI companies have been undermining human labor, and so on. Shallow or not, people have their reasons to avoid it.It’s like you brought a steak salad to a vegan potluck. Telling people they can pick the steak out isn’t what they want.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 1 point 3 months ago (2 children)

    I keep not understanding what you're talking about, the site is entirely developed by me, I haven't exploited anyone. And if you're talking about D&D instead, I'm not exploiting anyone's work: all the material on the site is free-copyright, and I specifically only pulled unofficial, unprotected documentation, whether it's the rules (which are free), the spell and monster database, etc. Every reference to the material I've drawn on is specifically credited, which makes my product a sponsor and an opportunity to introduce other people's work to more and more people. What people create in the site afterward is their own property. It's funny to me that you first compare my system to other, more famous ones, sneaking in flimsy criticism of the (entirely optional) use of AI, and then dwell on some supposed "inappropriate" use of other people's content, when the very sites you cite do the same thing, and not only that, they commercialize the product and profit from it, which I don't do. Through all of this, I haven't seen any response to all the other points I raised. ;)

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 3 months ago* (3 children)

    You even directly quoted the complaint that this is built on the backs of thousands of people's work. Without their consent, without the possibility of attribution and recognition for their work.

    And then blithely ignored it, failed to address it at all.

    You have demonstrated you just don't care about the creative work of countless people over countless hours, that has been shredded and fed into the machine which extruded this thing you want to promote. Why should anyone care about giving you “constructive” feedback? De-construct this thing and think a lot harder about the people you're trying to market to.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 3 months ago

    Interesting! I know Dark Sun is a well-regarded setting in many circles. I read one of the novels set there a long time ago, though I hadn't quite wrapped my head around the different DnD settings at that time. I was confused that Drizzt was nowhere to be found, let alone the other Forgotten Realms touchstones that I had conflated with DnD proper. I'm curious how the setting will be adapted for the modern era. Proclaiming its release window as the "Season of Survival" is kind of interesting. Seems like they could be encouraging people to engage with the most often neglected pillar of the DnD system (at least, in my experience playing with folks who largely started with 5e).

  • source
  • [–] [S] -3 points 3 months ago* (last edited 3 months ago) (5 children)

    The only thing I can see is that it’s “free”, but that’s freeness that is built on the backs of the lives and livlihoods of thousands of people.

    Sorry, what does even mean? Being free is already a significant incentive in itself. I hype AI features because, in my opinion, it's precisely the missing element in other systems. If you're a purist and feel my system offers nothing more, you're free to stick with your favorite sites. Instead, you could give me your idea of ​​what others are truly lacking that I could offer, since that's exactly what I'm looking for: constructive feedback on what I could implement to help the community.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 8 points 3 months ago (6 children)

    Going forward, I'd suggest reading the room better.

    All of your marketing documents hype up the AI features to the exclusion of all else. If I were such a "puritan" and turned off all AI features what does dragons roost offer that DndBeyond, roll20 and Foundry do not?

    The only thing I can see is that it's "free", but that's freeness that is built on the backs of the lives and livlihoods of thousands of people.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] -5 points 3 months ago (7 children)

    I understand the purists' skepticism, but Dice Roost offers a feature that can be used or not, nothing stops the DM from voicing the NPCs themselves, with or without the NPC chat open (there's a "puppet" feature that lets the DM answer on behalf of the NPC, forcing specific responses or avoiding LLM use entirely). The site is completely free and doesn't force anyone into an approach different from the one they want; at the same time, it gives less experienced DMs, or those who enjoy voicing NPCs less, the chance to use a new feature.

    I can assure you the voices are genuinely realistic with the right model, but I'd suggest trying it yourselves if you have doubts. Also, the system is designed to give the LLM sensible context so that NPCs respond consistently not just with their background, but with the game world they're in and the people they're talking to. It's certainly not perfect, the project just launched and has plenty of room for improvement, but from my tests it's very reliable and accurate when the game world is set up correctly.

    Regarding Vibe Coding: it exists and is used. I'm a Team Leader at an IT consulting firm, I've been using these tools well before they went mainstream, and the speed and reliability that modern development with this approach offers has no comparison to standard development, regardless of the team or the developer behind the keyboard. I don't intend to get into a technical discussion here about why developing this way is better, but assuming that Vibe development automatically means bugs makes me think you're either not in the field or don't know the tool at all.

    As for features, the system covers what I consider the basic functions any (system-agnostic) tabletop campaign needs: player and character sheet management, NPC management, maps, game chat with dice rolling. Many of these features are paired with AI-based additions aimed at improving them. For example: automatic NPC responses, where you can assign information that only unlocks with certain triggers (a key phrase, an item the party possesses, a party member's race, etc.), which pushes players to stay in character and use the right phrasing to uncover extra information useful for advancing the plot, but never essential to progressing (tier 1 and tier 2 info); automatic conversation summaries; the ability to "narrate" situations or locations as if it were a game or a film; a private GM-only chat where the GM can get answers about locations, NPCs, past events, the rules of the system being played, and more, to speed things up and help run campaigns. Again, all these features are free and not required to play.

    The only supported system today besides the "generic" one is D&D 5e, which offers additional features, a dedicated character sheet, bestiary, rulebook, and a complete spell and magic item list fully translated into Italian (in Italian, there's no VTT with a complete, free translation). In the future I want to implement other systems and let everyone create campaigns with their preferred ruleset, with dedicated features for each.

    The site is very young (it's been live for less than 72 hours) and isn't at version 1.0 yet. I'm looking for constructive feedback and suggestions on how to make it work for all types of players and DMs, whether or not they approve of AI use.

    Going forward, I'd suggest a more constructive and less toxic attitude toward someone offering a new tool for free, regardless of whether you think it's useful to the community. The people using it will be the ones to judge whether my project is any good.

    Thanks anyway for the input, and before you ask, no, I didn't generate this message with AI, believe it or not ;)

  • source
  • [–] 8 points 3 months ago

    So... Besides outsourcing creativity to world destroying megacorps, what other features does this vtt have? Like, if I have no interest in using tts for my npcs, what does your project offer? What systems does it support? How accurate and feature rich are they? How vibecoded (read: buggy) is the server backend and frontend?

  • source
  • [–] 5 points 3 months ago

    God...imagine playing with a bunch of NPC's with robotic voices that regularly fuck up the intonation and pronunciation of simple sentences all the time. There are few things I can think of that will break my immersion faster than this.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 3 months ago

    I'm playing in a Trail of Cthulhu campaign right now (Eternal Lies specifically), and honestly I like the system more than Call. Which is saying something, because Call of Cthulhu was the first RPG I ever played, and I have a lot of nostalgia for it. If you want Gumshoe and have people interested in CoC, maybe they could be convinced.

    Though I do love a lot of PbtA stuff as well.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 3 months ago (1 child)

    Never managed to find a group interested in playing gumshoe (it's either dnd or coc or some pbta gamearound here), would love to try in the future.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 3 months ago

    Maybe an unpopular opinion, but DND doesn't do Star Wars well. There's no adventuring day in the source fiction, really. Jedi are hard to model- they either shine too bright or don't live up to the fiction. Force powers don't really map to existing DND systems. Class+Level is very coarse, which makes it hard to model some concepts. DND is almost entirely a combat game, but I guess Star wars is mostly fighting so you won't feel the absence of other systems that much.

    I'm sure it'll be make some people happy. The previous d20 Star wars games had their fans. I just don't think it's something I'd enjoy, and it's a shame this is going to suck the air out of star wars tabletop game options.

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 3 months ago

    I LOVE Ynn and the Stygian Library and I want to run them in Savage Worlds so badly...

    ...but I also worry I'd get some wonky result and just not know what to do with it, or just get stuck and stall the whole game, or not know how to tie any of the events together.

    How was your experience along those lines?

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 3 months ago

    Daggerheart is our main TTRPG and the appeal is the it leans more on narrative and story telling. Its a lot more flexible in terms of rules than DnD. So no, no rules slog. The hope and fear dice make rolls feel more dynamic. But we like theatre of mind, Rule of Cool and whatnot so the narrative forward aspect of it appeals yo our play style.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 3 months ago

    In my experience, ttrpg players will set anything and everything on fire eventually.

    What specifically happens, or how you set them on fire, it's going to entirely depend on the rules of the game you're playing.

    For example, in a game like Dungeons and Dragons or Pathfinder, you may have a spell which can set fire to the boats from afar simple as.

    In Call of Cthulhu, you may need to roll a check to sneak past some guards to get to the ship and set light to it, and if you fail in your check you may find yourself getting captured and implanted with a mind control worm.

    In Fabula Ultima, setting light to the ships may actually be the main objective of a conflict playing out, and your progress and success may be measured by a ten slice clock. You have to weigh the option of spending your turn fighting off assailants, healing yourself or allies, or working towards filing that clock and succeeding at your main objective.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›