[–] 4 points 1 year ago (1 child)

Yes, everything in OG 2nd edition is basically compatible with the remaster. While you should generally use the updated version if available, the mechanics are so lightly tweaked for the most part that you will have no issues.

For organized Society play, you are allowed to use anything from the original 2nd edition that hasn’t been republished in a remastered version yet.

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago

    But it doesn't require being on top of them for the whole 6 second round. I view it as a brief shove, disrupting their action. Someone else can easily act before or after you. Or, as you described it as a foot stomp, they could act at the same time, on a part of the body that is...not where your foot is.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 1 year ago (1 child)

    The thing is, preventing someone from getting up - especially someone with any amount of combaat training - involves a lot more than just standing next to them. You have to get your weight on top of them, and then usually attack or manipulate one of the limbs.

    That is not an act that leaves you out of the way. It kind of means being on top of the target, at least while you're forcing them baack down.

    So, the Stay Down reaction kind of needs to be imagined as something that interferes with a strike that can be done without risking an ally.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago (2 children)

    I like your idea of looking to the fiction, but I disagree with the outcome in this case if you do. Allies don't generally get in the way of each other, they cooperate. To both be in range of Reactive Strike, you're probably standing on opposite or at least adjacent sides of the same enemy, not one physically behind the other where blocking might make sense.

    Your attempt to knock them back down shouldn't stop your ally attacking them as they try to stand.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 1 point 1 year ago

    I'm much more experienced in the system today than I was when I first posted this to the now-defunct pathfinder.social instance. But I've only had experience behind the screen, so I still don't have the hands-on player-side experience to give a fully-informed take.

    My feeling is that Charisma is already useful enough; I wouldn't want it to take over Will saves from Wisdom, which apart from Perception (including Initiative) feels like a relatively under-utilised ability.

    The Strength and Constitution merger seems like a really good one.

    I'm largely undecided on dex. The fact that by splitting them you are also allowing the new Dexterity to apply damage on finesse attacks is really cool. I like how that sort of offsets the inherit nerf dex is getting by being split, so it's nerfed a little less in these specific ways. But now the typical rogue has three abilities that they really rely on in combat (dex, agi, str) instead of just two (dex, con). (Or 4 instead of 3, if you want to add wis for perception.) Not to mention now the thief racket loses their main bonus.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 1 year ago (3 children)

    So very often, these types of questions remain fully mired in the realm of naked mechanics, but I find it helpful to imagine what's actually happening in the fiction. The mechanics are there to aid the fiction at the table, after all.

    So, what's taking place during Stay Down!? How is the creature keeping the target down?

    To me, this has real "stomp" energy, where the user is putting their foot on the target's back, or dropping a knee on them, or something, while yelling at them to stay down. The target tries to get up, but is forced back down to the ground before they can really move -- after all, if the prone creature can get up into a plank position, or up onto their hands and knees, it becomes significantly harder to force them back into a prone position.

    That is to say, it happens very early.

    Reactive Strike, on the other hand, is about looking for openings to strike, where the target has let their guard slip (or abandoned it altogether). This is why it applies when the target is trying to stand -- it's very hard to defend yourself from a determined attacker when you're transitioning from lying prone to getting into almost any other position.

    But when the first creature uses Stay Down, they are functionally putting themselves between the target and anyone else who might want to strike. An ally might not want to take the chance in this situation, particularly since the fiction is not "attacking someone who's being held down", but "attacking at the same time that your ally is getting in the way".

    Topple Foe, on the other hand, is entirely about taking advantage of a distracted or staggered target and trying to sweep or tackle them to the ground. And unlike Stay Down! and Reactive Strike in the first example, it doesn't even have the same mechanical trigger as the reaction you're trying to pair it with. This is just a pure tag team shine spot.

  • source
  • [–] [S] 2 points 1 year ago

    The video is definitely front-loaded wrt the more interesting ones.

    I like 1 in theory, but once you get Devastating Attacks or Striking runes, it starts getting more difficult to get the dice and to add up all those numbers. Much quicker to just stick with the official rule.

    2 is great. I might start using it.

    3: I already partly did. I find my players are so reticent to use Recall Knowledge in combat that I'll just do anything I can to give them benefits and make it easier.

    4: I don't really care for the rigid "declare one of these 4 actions" structure of exploration the official rules use. I ignore it completely for a much more free-flowing narrative.

    5: hasn't been a problem in my experience.

    6: People actually use XP?

    7–11: I haven't encountered any of these.

    12: moving creatures around the initiative order is too much of a pain. They act when they show up in the order. But they can have reactions immediately.

    13: Has never come up for me, but I like this house rule

    14–19: have just never come up for me

    20: I guess it's cool if you want it. To me the whole point of the ABP is to cut out all the progression of magic items, and leave them entirely as cool extra effects. So I don't want to reintroduce any of that.

    21: sounds cool in theory. I don't think Pathbuilder supports it, either with or without Ronald's changes. And I certainly don't like it enough to ask my players to manage it custom.

    22: for origin archetypes, this is already RAW. Not something I care enough about to run otherwise.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 1 year ago

    A$8.50 Level

    • Pathfinder 2e Beginner Box (Remastered)
    • Lost Omens: World Guide
    • GM Core (Remastered)
    • Iconic Pregenerated Characters
    • Character Sheet Pack
    • Advanced Players Guide Character Sheet Pack
    • Adventure: A Fistfull of Flowers
    • Adventure: A Few Flowers More

    A$25.50 Level

    • Player Core (Remastered)
    • Adventure: Rusthenge
    • Adventure: Crown of the Kobold King
    • Bounty: Sodden Stories
    • Bounty: Somewhere Below
    • PF Quest: Falcon's Descent
    • Flip Mat: Crown of the Kobold King
    • Flip Mat: Rusthenge
    • Flip Mat: Jungle Multi-Pack
    • Flip Tiles: Darklands Starter Set
    • Flip Mat: Twisted Caverns
    • GM Core GM Screen

    A$51 Level

    • Monster Core (Remastered)
    • Player Core 2 (Remastered)
    • Lost Omens: Highhelm
    • Sky King's Tomb - Player's Guide
    • Sky King's Tomb Part 1 of 3 - Mantle of Gold
    • Sky King's Tomb Part 2 of 3 - Cult of the Cave Worm
    • Sky King's Tomb Part 3 of 3 - Heavy is the Crown

    A$76 Level (+ shipping, this is a physical product, with limited stock)

    • Monster Core Sketch Cover
  • source
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago

    Thanks for sharing. That was really interesting. I really liked the restaurant menu analogy. When I first explored PF2, I was put off by the vancian casting, but it's really interesting to hear about how actually, PF2 has a much more varied approach with all these other classes (some of which didn't exist at the time).

    The explanation in this video of the Animist actually sounds quite a lot like the D&D 5e warlock, which has long been what I've said is the biggest thing missing in Pathfinder. I doubt the Animist is truly going to scratch that same itch, but I'm going to look through the Animist out of interest regardless.

    I was a little disappointed that this video didn't actually discuss the strict vancianism which I expected it to based on the title. But I look forward to watching his next video, since he said that will cover it.

  • source
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›