Sweet I've been interested in Deflect as an alternative to CF since I noticed Cory Doctorow using it on his 'pluralistic' website.
comments
Post this on Reddit too, so more people come here. /r/BuyCanadian is a good sub for posting this.
Oh I thought it was daily but you are right it's monthly (it's super hard to see it on my phone screen). One of the buttons on the bottom, for Additional Checks Data, has data provided multiple times per day, if someone wants to make a chart from the raw numbers.
I wish it was weekly or daily, it doesn't really pop and a good image is so important.
I didn't think it would work on reddit 🤔 but could try
The middle one at https://piefed.fediverse.observer/piefed.ca should work nicely:-)
Ew.
It is totally reasonable and sensible to not want to mix personal account and business account. I think that's a good move.
As for the rest, you are probably wrong to assume things and there are a LOT of things you assumed in that post. Don't make assumptions. Use data. Figure out what works and what doesn't. Facts, not feelings. Has anyone called you a grifter? Did you get downvotes and they get upvotes? Does it happen every time? Sites like these can work like random number generators sometimes. Sometimes it works. Sometimes it doesn't. Even having a small business is a risk. You can't avoid all risk. You have to accept some risk. Your reputation can get tainted, yes, but I don't actually think that's very likely, certainly not as likely as you seem to think it is, and even if it does it can also be repaired. Yes it might take some work, but running a business also takes work. If you are not willing to take risk or do work when those risks don't pay off, then I don't know what else to tell you.
I will say it again in case I wasn't clear the first time. In my own personal opinion, and my experience on this site so far, it is perfectly fine for you to advertise your business here. I do not run this site or moderate it and I cannot speak for the admins or for everyone else, I am only one person, but you will get my upvote and maybe my support in the comments. I hope that helps.
Personally, I'd advise against self-promotion. It's never been well perceived. But it depends for what and where.
If a local band or troupe or artist were to advertise a show or an exhibit in their city's community, I'd be fine with it. But if someone is trying to push a brand or product, I'd be against it unless it's in a community meant for that, like buycanadian or something like that. But it better be for a Canadian product or brand.
The problem though is this could open the door to other advertisers and things could get quickly out of control. So that's why I'd prefer that people refrain from advertising at all in communities.
Maybe just create your own community for your brand or product, which you could moderate yourself.
My opinion as somebody with no real skin in the game: Post where you want. Especially in communities like "BuyCanadian" or communities for your own product or whatever, as long as the community is okay with it and your post or comment makes sense there, and you're not posting so frequently that people are getting sick of it, I don't think there's anything wrong with that. And you don't have to take my word for it. If there is anything wrong with what you're doing, and even if you're not, the delightful thing about the internet is that there's never any shortage of people willing to tell you frequently and usually with exceptional levels of sarcasm or vitriol. If your posts are not welcome, people will have no problem making you feel very unwelcome. If that's not happening, you probably have very little to worry about.
The "no self promotion" rule on Reddit was, in my opinion, one of the worst rules in the way that it frequently victimized genuine responsible people who I'd actually like to hear from, without actually doing much of anything to stop the people or content it was presumably or allegedly intended to stop. I understand it might have actually made sense at some points or in some communities, but it never needed to be a site-wide rule (except that they wanted to sell ads instead of letting people advertise for free). Plus I think it was often selectively enforced in ways that were not actually reasonable or genuine and I don't think it made much of a useful impact on stopping spam or bots or dishonest people. They just found more ways to dishonest about it. It was the honest people who it punished. And to what end, aside from Reddit's bottom line?
I believe in supporting real independent businesses, and in order to do that, I need to know who they are, where they are, and what they're selling. That can be very difficult, especially when they are assumed to be obnoxious spammers by default and never given an opportunity to prove themselves. We have a voting system for a reason. We have moderators who can see people's histories for a reason. If you're abusing the site, you'll find out quickly. If you're a real person with genuine motivations, I doubt you are abusing the site. I doubt anything resembling abuse would even enter your mind to do. And if you do by accident, you'll quickly pull back when you're told you've gone too far (probably by too much, honestly, most people take grumpy trolls having a bad day way too seriously). Be reasonable, and don't be unreasonable.
Also, if your posts here bring in any business, be a responsible person and support the community by making at least some small donation to the site. It doesn't have to be pay-as-you-go. This is not a zero-sum game of profits and losses. This is a community. Be part of it, and we can support each other.
Look into Piefed. It’s far superior and made by better people
Hey, a hearty welcome to you. I appreciate you and everyone who's recently made the jump to try the Threadiverse (Lemmy, Piefed etc.)
Just know as a small but growing community, many of the existing members are ideologues with strong beliefs, since everyone on Lemmy/Piefed has at the very least made a conscious choice to seek an alternative to big tech. Depending on what interface you're using, the scores aren't hidden by default, so you may see downvotes on some of your genuine opinions and questions, please don't take it personally. On lemmy.ca and most general communities, you won't be banned just for an unpopular opinion presented earnestly, so long as you avoid being reflexively defensive and obnoxious about it.
Can we try to approach discussion with the initial sentiment of sincerity and authenticity?
Yes, I believe so, I've been striving to since I started using Lemmy. To elaborate on what you said, it's all of our responsibility to keep trolling and flame-war-baiting to a minimum, and to engage in more meaningful, insightful conversations of both shared and differing beliefs.
Well hello! Bonjour!
Sadly that would exclude PieFed.ca users, an instance we also manage :(
Not Canadian myself but I like following news from the country, and so I also keep an eye in posts from lemmy.ca. That said, I don't remember having seen a community for a similar proposal. And considering the changes worldwide and how province-related issues in my own country seem similar to Canada's, as an outsider I think there's potential for discussion right there.
Also a tip, there's !newcommunities@lemmy.world you should also be able to post to, in case you want to reach a broader audience. And you should be able to make a mention to the community in threads and their comments with !ProvincialDiscussionCanada@lemmy.ca (like I did in the previous phrase) so other users can quickly access the community, and not have to reconstruct the link or look for it.
What province you from?
I am brand new, as are a lot of us since a big influx from Reddit.
I am Canadian, and my comments are sincere.
I don’t claim to be nor want to be a moral authority, and I don’t dictate the direction of this place. I wanted to give my comments on how I personally think we can collectively try to keep the community cohesive and civil and higher trust.
It’s just some of my thoughts, it’s up to everyone else to decide whether they agree or not, of course!
Lol!
Anyone else getting "foreign-actor" vibes from this post?
Brand new guy, yet immediately trying to establish some kind of moral authority and/or direction over something that existed long before him?
Doesn't sound very Canadian.
Thank you for writing that out 😊
It's also more genuine and transparent. Mod actions are public and votes are auditable, out of necessity for how the software works.
On Reddit the votes are private, fuzzed, and people buying upvotes/downvotes have been a consistent problem for years.
If you get 10 upvotes on here, you're much more likely to have reached 10 real human beings than on Reddit.
We have some information here, but that page is already out of date since Piefed is pretty stable now.
https://fedecan.ca/en/guide/fedecan/our-platforms
It's been harder to make an accurate comparison as both projects are under active development and either have, or are working on many of the same features.
The extra features on Piefed that I personally use are scheduled posts and topic lists.
Welcome! Feel free to ask any questions that come up, the community here is very helpful :)
If Fedecan funding ever ceases to pay the bills, is there a plan in place, or does it shut down?
Realistically it would probably just shut down, but our donations are more than covering our expenses at the moment and the site is still growing. I don't have any concerns about not being able to pay the bills. The site only costs us about $200/mo to run so it's not a huge amount, but I'll admit it's only that low due to my donating a server worth around $40k (when it was new, although it'd be like $80k today thanks to ram prices).
May I suggest looking at government grants and funding if they don’t interfere with your goal and operations, especially now, the government is looking to boost Canadian enterprise.
Honestly, that sounds like a lot of work 😂 I'm not keen on spending time writing up business growth docs and having meetings, my day job has enough of that for me. If someone else comes along and wants to join the org + help drive that then we'd probably be open to it, but we've all got busy lives and it's not a priority for us.
do those working with Fedecan pay themselves for their work?
Nope. It's something we've discussed, but for now we're all on board with keeping things lightweight and not trying to turn this into wikipedia with regular fund raisers to pay salaries.