I get asked this question a lot by people who are aware of Gnostic philosophy or come from belief systems where an evil god of this world would contradict a lot of what they believe. The traditional answers from Abrahamic faiths are that humans or evil spirits cause suffering. Others are more sympathetic and say the demiurge lacks understanding or clarity, so he makes poor decisions without ill intent. I don’t find either answer convincing, for three overlapping reasons: what the texts show him doing, how they treat his adversaries, and how blame for his actions moved onto those adversaries over time. A note on terms. In classic Gnostic sources like the Apocryphon of John, the demiurge is a lesser being named Yaldabaoth. The Bible, the Qur’an, and the Book of Mormon don’t use that name, so when I apply it to the God of these texts, that is my interpretation. Throughout, I am describing what the scriptures say, not claiming the events happened. First, the texts themselves. The holy land of these traditions is Israel, and the god who claims it commands his people to destroy the nations living there. In my reading, that makes it hard to argue he is ignorant or benevolent. According to Genesis, he drowns nearly all life in a flood. According to Exodus, he kills every firstborn in Egypt after hardening Pharaoh’s heart so Pharaoh can’t relent. According to the Book of Mormon, he buries, burns, and sinks whole cities and ends the Jaredite civilization in a war of extermination. Other stories are strange rather than cruel: in Exodus 4 he tries to kill Moses at an inn for no stated reason, and in 1 Kings 22 he sends a lying spirit to trick a king into dying in battle. The texts present him as evil, morally slippery, or completely insane, depending on the passage. The doctrines built on these stories have real effects. Teachings like eternal punishment for unbelief and obedience to authority without question can be used to justify cruelty toward others. Evangelical Christianity is probably the branch of demiurge worship most people have experience with, but other traditions carry their own versions. Second, the texts say little about demons, and when they do, the demons look comparatively less evil. In the Book of Enoch, the Watchers have children with humans and teach metalworking and cosmetics. They also teach weapons-making and sorcery, and their giant children eat all the food and then turn on people. A critic will point to that, but notice what it does in the story: it justifies the Flood. The offense becomes the reason for killing nearly everything alive, and the punishment dwarfs it. Asmodeus kills seven husbands of a woman named Sarah in Tobit, which is terrible, but it is small next to the floods and burning cities. Korihor, in the Book of Mormon, is told by a disguised angel to preach against God. All he does is persuade people, and God strikes him mute and he is trampled to death. In the Qur’an, Iblis refuses to bow to Adam, and he is cursed, allowed to tempt humanity, and promised hell. A believer could answer that a creator who gives life has the right to take it, so the comparison would be unfair if we accept this premise. But that answer concedes my point. The texts hold the demiurge to a different standard than anyone else, giving him moral impunity for the deaths of millions while his adversaries are punished severely for acts as small as refusing to bow or giving people makeup. Third, many dark deeds now attributed to Satan and demons were originally attributed to the demiurge. The clearest case is David’s census. In 2 Samuel 24, God incites David to take it and then punishes Israel with a plague. In 1 Chronicles 21, the same story has Satan doing the inciting. In Job, Satan is a member of God’s court, and in 1 Samuel 16, an evil spirit from the Lord torments King Saul. Over the centuries Satan grows from an official in God’s service into a full rival, and by the Qur’an and the Book of Mormon he is a complete adversary. I think this shift moved the dark deeds off the demiurge so these belief systems would have a more sympathetic figure to worship. The adversary figures are still being blamed for what the earlier texts gave to God, and organized religion continues guiding the masses deeper into ignorance by keeping them from asking whether the god they worship is the one doing the harm.
posts
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
view more:
next ›


