all 4 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 38 points 8 months ago
[–] 11 points 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago)

The standard of originality is low, but it does exist. ... [T]he Constitution mandates some minimal degree of creativity ... and an author who claims infringement must prove “the existence of . . . intellectual production, of thought, and conception.” Burrow-Giles.

  • source
  • [–] 25 points 8 months ago (1 child)

    To be clear, and I'm kinda annoyed this article doesn't mention it at all, this case was about some idiot trying to register a copyright under his robot's name. The case isn't saying that AI-generated stuff can't be copyrighted, it's saying that an AI can't hold a copyright.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 22 points 8 months ago

    The case isn't saying that AI-generated stuff can't be copyrighted

    Yes, it is.

    After reviewing the statutory text, judicial precedent, and longstanding Copyright Office practice, the Board again concludes that human authorship is a prerequisite to copyright protection in the United States and that the Work therefore cannot be registered.

    https://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2022/03/copyright-office-rejects-registration-for-ai-created-works.htm

    As to whether or not you can claim copyright for something that you didn't produce, that was already decided by the monkey selfie incident

    Slater has argued that he has a valid copyright claim because he engineered the situation that resulted in the pictures by travelling to Indonesia, befriending a group of wild macaques, and setting up his camera equipment in such a way that a selfie photograph taken by one of the animals might come about.

    And yet, he doesn't hold a copyright on that image because the picture was taken by the monkey. That's why Wikimedia is allowed to host that image against his wishes.

    So, you can't claim that your AI Waifu held the copyright and transferred it to you, because your AI Waifu can't hold a copyright. You can't claim that it's actually you who did the work because, as the monkey case shows, the ultimate creative act has to have been yours.

    The US copyright office has also made this clear in a publication in the federal register:

    Individuals who use AI technology in creating a work may claim copyright protection for their own contributions to that work. They must use the Standard Application,[39] and in it identify the author(s) and provide a brief statement in the “Author Created” field that describes the authorship that was contributed by a human. For example, an applicant who incorporates AI-generated text into a larger textual work should claim the portions of the textual work that is human-authored. And an applicant who creatively arranges the human and non-human content within a work should fill out the “Author Created” field to claim: “Selection, coordination, and arrangement of [describe human-authored content] created by the author and [describe AI content] generated by artificial intelligence.” Applicants should not list an AI technology or the company that provided it as an author or co-author simply because they used it when creating their work.

    AI-generated content that is more than de minimis should be explicitly excluded from the application.[40] This may be done in the “Limitation of the Claim” section in the “Other” field, under the “Material Excluded” heading. Applicants should provide a brief description of the AI-generated content, such as by entering “[description of content] generated by artificial intelligence.” Applicants may also provide additional information in the “Note to CO” field in the Standard Application.

    https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/03/16/2023-05321/copyright-registration-guidance-works-containing-material-generated-by-artificial-intelligence

    So, if someone vibe-codes something, none of the resulting code can be copyrighted. It's all machine generated. If they make some minor edits to the machine generated code, the portion that they edit can be copyrighted, but the vast majority can't be copyrighted. If it's an AI-generated slop video, the slop video can't be copyrighted, but the prompts for it could be.

  • source
  • parent
  • 4 comments in c/hackernews@lemmy.bestiver.se view that post
    [–] 9 points 8 months ago (2 children)

    This headline implies a misunderstanding of what this case is actually about. This is the Thaler v. Perlmutter case. Thaler has been arguing - since 2018, before the current AI "boom" - that the copyright of a particular image that he'd generated with an AI belonged to the AI itself rather than to him.

    The copyright office, and every court he's appealed to since then, have responded "AIs aren't legal persons and so cannot hold copyright." That's all this Supreme Court rejection is affirming. It's a really obvious outcome, Thaler is basically a loon with too much money and time on his hands for continuing to pursue the case.

    It doesn't address the general copyrightability of AI-generated art. In this particular case Thaler is explicitly saying "I don't hold the copyright, my AI holds the copyright." The courts have said "well, if you don't hold the copyright and the AI can't hold the copyright, that means nobody holds the copyright and therefore this particular piece is in the public domain." Thaler is allowed to disclaim his own copyright over the work, he just can't assign it to an AI like this.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 6 points 8 months ago* (1 child)

    So is it fair to say (in your view) that the case is more about AI personhood than copyright itself?

    Headline definitely seems misleading. Even some parts of the body of the article try and push it the other way.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 5 points 8 months ago

    Yeah. And "personhood" in the legal sense, which is already pretty well defined. If Thaler had made a corporation to hold that copyright then this would be an entirely different situation.

    Thaler v. Perlmutter has been cropping up under this headline again and again over the years since the courts keep ruling against him and "AI-generated art can't be copyrighted" is an extremely popular bait for clicks. The one positive about this particular cycle is that now that the Supreme Court has ruled he may finally be out of ways to have yet another do-over. This might be the last one.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 7 points 8 months ago

    Does this means that I can just take someone's AI generated music and reuse it however I want? Or is licensing something different and you cpuld still get DMCA?

  • source