Your respose is a perfect example of how wrong the left wing response is to this sort of situation. You've been handed two pies, one is undercooked, the other literal faeces. The pie being undercooked has nothing to do with the apple tree, and the other pie doesn't have any apples in it, so your response of 'burn down the tree that produced the fruit' addresses neither issue, and cuts off the supply of fresh apples for everyone until your new tree, hopefully, starts to bear fruit sometime in the future.

If, instead, you'd said something along the lines of "lets teach people how to check their pies are actually cooked, and how to tell the difference between fruit and faeces", then you'd have been on to something.