I wish there were better USB-PD trigger modules available. Specifically, the things I hate about all the readily available ones:- If requested voltage isn't available, you get a lower voltage on the output instead of zero. For many applications this is fine, but for some things undervoltage is destructive.- Backfeeding from load into USB. If the load also has a battery, or even has a capacitor that might still be charged to >5V, that gets fed back into the USB + line before PD negotiation can happen. This usually prevents negotiation from happening at all and could be destructive.Fixing these is probably slightly nontrivial, but can't be that bad, and it would be so much nicer to have $1 triggers that are actually safe/reliable than 25¢ ones that are garbage.

1 comment

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] [S] 1 point 20 hours ago

I understand why it happens: the dirt cheap triggers just connect the USB +/- dirtectly to output +/- and only mess with the pins that negotiate voltage.And because (for type A, I think) it's possible you already have +5V before any negotiation happens, the "getting a lower voltage than you requested" problem is already there, and it's not any worse (generally, only better) if you get a voltage in between 5V and what you requested.A fix requires mosfets to switch the load. But there are cheap tiny-package mosfets fine for the currents involved and no high-frequency switching.

  • source