TL;DR:
Space is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly hugely mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space
TL;DR:
Space is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly hugely mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space
It is not a paradox, we are speed running towards human extinction. Thus providing a very simple reason why intelligent life doesn’t last long and defines a simple great filter.
What we consider intelligent is quite subjective
I like the theory that any life advanced enough to explore the galaxy is watching humanity in disgust and avoiding us like the plague while waiting for our self-induced extinction.
There's probably life all over the place like on earth but it's very primitive.
It took 3.5 billion years to get to the point where we evolved enough to be able to ask this question. 3.5 billion years of near misses, mass extinction events, and our star remaining stable enough to not wipe us out. I suspect microbial life is very common, we might even find some in our solar system but sentient life much less so and sentient life existing at the same time that we do is even rarer let alone sentient life creating radio waves over a long enough period to coincide with our very recent attempts to receive it.
Earth has been giving off obvious chemical evidence of life signs for eons. Any Type 1 civilization would have seen it a long time ago and we would stand out like glass on the beach.
Even if they haven't arrived to check it out, which I doubt, they will be watching carefully in various ways.
So: zoo hypothesis seems more likely than anything to me.
Earth has been giving off obvious chemical evidence of life signs for eons.
True, like I said microbial life is likely found all over the galaxy but we've only been transmitting radio waves for a little over a century.
Even if they haven’t arrived to check it out, which I doubt, they will be watching carefully in various ways.
How would they travel, realistically? Also what are these various ways that they will be watching?
It's impossible to be "realistic" about travel, as it is one of the things where we don't know how little we know. We theorize about alcubierre warp fields and wormholes or generation ships or machine intelligences but isn't that like saying you can't canoe to the moon without a better paddle? Do our paleo ancestors have anything to say about ion drives or plutonium energy sources?
I appreciate all the skeptics on space travel, but so many fall down on turning the same skepticism on our own limits to knowledge, and assume we know enough to make conclusive assumptions about something we have never tried.
True, but we still have to try and understand the universe within the scientific framework we've built otherwise we're just indulging in science fiction. We know things like the distances involved, the time it would take to travel those distances even at a high percentage of the speed of light, the amount of energy needed to move a specific mass, and so on.
Maybe there are ways around this for sufficiently advanced beings but maybe there is intelligent life within 100 light years of us that is listening to the first radio broadcasts with no way of getting here.
Yes. My point is that the theoretical approach is
Sent from my tricorder/communicator combo unit
Species who gain intelligence goofily try pushing toward space while letting their home planets environement go. They go nuts on pulling resources from their planet to try and put members of the species on planets that are not at all habitable like their homeplanet or to throw things at the stars when they can't get past the speed of light. All the while their planet becomes less and less habitable and they don't try to just live sustainably as a species on their planet.
I believe for us the answer is a very depressing one, I think organic intelligence almost always is superseded by more durable and effectively unlimited inorganic intelligence. That the intelligence exploring the universe is all machine we are regarded as a dull precursor wet phase to what they hope will emerge and they have no interest in interactions with slime.
People who believe in there ever being "contact" do not comprehend the size and nature of the universe.
Rule one, it's expanding, rule 2, faster than light.
We'll never achieve relativistic speed, our physiology doesn't allow "generational ships", a fetuses brain will never develop to intelligence in freefall. Centrifugal force is not gravity.
The belief in alien intelligence is simply going to be an exercise for theocracy and philosophy, never to manifest in our reality.
Maybe as the universe evolves new physics emerge allowing for new technology, the universe was once in fact so hot physics didn't work as we identify with it but contact within humanities existence probably won't happen. Nice to think about though, it's in our nature for community due to our emotional intelligence, sometimes lack thereof providing contrast.
The replies to this story are making me lose faith in humanity.
Well the Drake equation is quite speculative but we are gradually filling in blanks. Exoplanets for example. It's just those last few terms that are tricky. If we found evidence of prehistoric life on Mars that might help as well. But the general response that intelligent life is always doomed and we all deserve to die for making occasionally stupid decisions is unhealthy I agree.
The alien races travel around the galaxy (anti-spinwise), collecting promising species along the way and helping them evolve into space faring races like themselves. Humanity evolved too fast, or wasn't noticed the last time around, but they'll be here "soon" - within 10 million years.
The answer is obvious, it's just not anthropocentric, so no one bothers to think of it.
When you look out at the sky, you see the results of a universe engineered by an intelligent species. You can't tell, for the same reason a hippo looking out at a nature preserve can't tell they are in a curated environment that has been made to appear to them as natural as possible, set aside for preservation.
We are ants, farting into the cosmos, wondering why no one else farts back. To think that radio waves and visible light are the height of understanding and interacting with the universe, is on its face nonsense.
We can't even maintain homeostasis on a single tiny planet that started with the most perfect conditions a universe could ever have for us. Why oh why do the "brightest minds" think that we have the tools to communicate with or even observe those who traverse solar systems, much less galaxies or the universe itself?
Pure ego. Look at all the "great filter possibilities" people propose. They're all "what if monkey forest, but bigger". Sure Ken, the unfathomable universe is just "big monkey forest".
But how does this differ from some God preserving humans for their own reasons or fairies doing it magically for that matter. Unknowable superhuman forces isnt a useful starting hypothesis for this question. After all how can it be tested? There doesn't seem to be anything it proves or disproves.
Which theories for "the great silence" are currently testable? Which ones currently prove or disprove anything?
This theory is at least evidence based. If you'd like to know how it specifically differs from a specific theory, I'm happy to explain just like below.
The way it differs from some god or faeries preserving humans is that;
Physical existence is only one aspect of it. Roswell itself was proof that some freaky-ass shit was personally witnessed by no less than 30 people, but we can’t count that because . . Um . . Reasons.
Nuts-and-bolts contact on the WH front lawn isn’t likely. And serious scientific questions are very much tied to physical, nuts-and-bolts answers. That doesn’t mean “no” or “never”.
Ive been reading books and papers for years by people involved with SETI and various adjacent fields, and the consensus is that earth is probably special, and basically alone. Not unique, necessarily, but so special as to preclude another intelligent species existing anywhere we could access it within the same window of time as we are around and hypothetically capable of communicating. Which from a space exploring perspective so far is around 100 years, blink of a cosmic eye.
The transition from non-life to life is something we don't understand fully, but what we do think we know about it indicates life itself, ultra-simple barely-life is common. With the right chemicals in a dish you can build a cell analogue that goes “searching” for more food chemical. And we’ve found proteins can be made by non-organic processes. Basic life seems pretty easy, just takes the right conditions, which also seem pretty common. Deep sea vents would exist on any liquidy planet with an active core. They might be slush instead of superheated, but its the gradient causing the movement, and nutrients being moved, that matters, not the temp.
But life as we know it did a flip from anaerobic to aerobic, something speculated to be vital to higher-order life on earth-like planets. The mass release of oxygen as a waste product is almost guaranteed as long as there is oxygen to be found, at any rate. That oxygen waste nearly wiped out earth life. Its possible that in more homogenous environments, it would entirely wipe it out. So thats one major hurdle we made it over that isn't necessarily likely.
(I’m gunna skip a bunch of intermediary steps that are also highly unlikely, like photosynthetic organisms being symbiotic relationships, as are animal mitochondria. These things aren't all strictly necessary, and I don't find it worth the effort to sort through them, just adding this to say this is not the sum of the argument in favor of earth’s special status)
Then you get to intelligent life. We’ve had multiple slate-clears in the form of mass extinctions, but advanced intelligence of the sort we have only popped up once that we know of in over 4 billion years (a handful of concurrent times if you count the other hominid species, but I'm counting them all as one since theres no way to know how isolated they really were and it probably doesn't make a difference to this anyway). Is it unlikely? Is it unlikely that intelligent species develop technology? I mean we have a lot of complex creatures on earth that are smart and capable socially, at least as much as we are, yet none of them created fire or electricity.
Personally I think life is probably incredibly common, since thats just rolling 2d6 and hoping for snake eyes, but intelligent life either understands the planet they are on is their best shot and has no real interest in space, or they simply don't exist alongside us in a way we will ever be able to appreciate (died out before we evolved, too far to contact, no way to make technology [no hands], no access to the surface of the planet [ocean moons and the like], or in the process of evolving. Perhaps their tech surpassed ours and we cant find them. Lots of stuff.)
I fond that conclusion to be rather sad, mostly because humans are fucking up so hard, it would be so nice to have role models..
all 31 comments