you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 21 points 14 hours ago (3 children)

Developing the first Librem phone was an unmitigated disaster that also revealed some serious problems with the company and its leader.

I never hear about people actually using it reporting back, these days. Of course there's always some zealots who will say "great experience, couldn't wish for more" through clenched teeth, while holding an overheating slab of tiny Debian between two fingers: "but it's got hardware switches!"

Oh and there was at least one shill. Not directly paid, more like wowed by the CEO. It was so sad, back then.

Speaking of which, how have the physical switches passed the test of time? Even buttons are usually the first thing to go, but actual switches... considering the quality of the rest of the device...

Here's the most comprehensive write-up: https://jaylittle.com/post/view/2019/10/the-sad-saga-of-purism-and-the-librem-5-part-1/ but there's much more, mostly as youtube videos.


Of course it's possible they got better. I wonder.


This article gets hung up on the price, even asks about it, when the question has been answered a thousand times: components that are more expensive, but most importantly producing in small batches will drive prices up like this, it's normal. Sheesh.

  • source
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 13 points 12 hours ago

    I never hear about people actually using it reporting back, these days. Of course there’s always some zealots who will say “great experience, couldn’t wish for more” through clenched teeth, while holding an overheating slab of tiny Debian between two fingers

    I bought one in July 2024. I use it every day, running Mobian. Before that, I had a PinePhone Pro. For me, it's the best phone which was designed upfront to run close-to-mainline linux (which is a small competition to win). I carry a dumphone with me for urgent calls. But, I bought it knowing the limitations, and for me, the free software angle is the important one, so I don't need to clench my teeth.

    I never pre-ordered it, so I don't feel much personal animosity towards them. I wouldn't trust them as far as I can throw them with a crowdfund. Cancelling refunds that they promised would be available, incredibly optimistic timelines, poor communication etc. are of course wrong. And, apart from saying no refunds upfront this time, they seem to be repeating many of the mistakes with this crowdfund too.

    But, they delivered a phone to me. I like the phone. It's widely supported by mobile linux distros. They funded some upstream work. For a certain niche, it's the best available.

    how have the physical switches passed the test of time?

    Mine are fine. I don't use them that often though.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 4 hours ago

    I ordered Librem 5 in 2021, waited for a few years to finally get it. I had hoped that the phone would work smoothly as any other phone, but I didn't actually expect that to happen.

    It is really easy to be critical of the rollout and the company communication etc. especially when the consumer market has very high expectations from tech manufacturers. The reality is that building from scratch is always hard.

    The reasons you haven't heard much from people actually using them and only seem to hear from youtube content creators about all of the bad things about them is because the phone does not function as a consumer product, nor has that ever been the intention. Content creators are trying to profit from a broad audience, and negativity bias makes bad reviews more profitable.

    The people actually using the device aren't using it because they need a mobile that accesses email and connects to social media, they are using it because it offers the user autonomy over their digital lives, something no other tech company in the world is offering the public right now.

    Current users understand that everything that we see in our lives is the end product of years of development and iterations, trial-and-error, failed attempts, miraculous surprises, and anything else imaginable. The first vacuum cleaner wasn't on 'dirt patrol' mode sucking its way through our living rooms and terrorizing our cats on its own while we are at work for the day.

    The point is, there is no phone device in the world today that offers digital autonomy, and so the first one that comes along likely isn't going to be the best phone on the market. Having the expectation that it should be able to compete with the iphone or whatever is a failure on the consumer's part, rather than it being a failure of the company that is trying to create change in the digital world.

    My librem 5 might not be able to access a shared google doc for my work, but I don't want it to. I can't input my credit card information and be able to tap at the checkout counter, but again, I don't want that. What I do want is to actually own something that I buy, be in control of what it does, and I want the freedom to be able to interact with the real and digital worlds without some middle man in between skimming data and profiting off of my personal life habits and digital footprints.

    I might be a little bit on the 'tinfoil hat' end of the spectrum when it comes to people tracking my digital life, but I understand that the choices I make in that regard means that the things that I choose to use in my life won't be the most convenient, or easiest, or cheapest, or fastest, or any of those things, and the Librem 5 is certainly none of those. But it works.

    Recently I missed my flight out of Edinburgh and needed to purchase a new ticket right away so I didn't miss my connecting flight and get stranded in Toronto. Apparently you can't buy plane tickets at the counter in airports anymore, you have to do it through the airlines app or online. It was very inconvenient to find a spot at the airport where I could get a strong enough signal so that I could access a desktop version of the airline's website on my Librem 5 to be able to get a ticket, but it worked.

    But for real, I am writing this on my Librem 5 which I use daily to access the digital world. I am currently using a Blackberry Classic as my daily driver dumb phone because it is also digitally isolated from the surveillance industry, but mostly because it has a physical keyboard. Actually, the keyboard is the reason I am not going to be getting a Librem 5 v2.

    Linux phones are growing in popularity these days and more options are becoming available all the time. Some of them have physical keyboards, some don't. I'm waiting for a linux phone that offers the digital autonomy of Purism with the ability to install whatever operating system I want, but that also has a physical keyboard. Until then my Blackberry still works, and my Librem 5 is ready on standby for when I really need it.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 0 points 9 hours ago

    Of course there's always some zealots who will say "great experience, couldn't wish for more" through clenched teeth, while holding an overheating slab of tiny Debian between two fingers: "but it's got hardware switches!"

    Sounds like editorializing to me

  • source
  • parent