My friend and I spent days in-game exploring that island. Starting from the beginning, trying different paths. Spending hours just stacking things to see what we could get to. The satisfying weight of objects, that wasn't even really present in the Source engine—6 years later meow. Getting to the abandoned city felt truly epic. Discovering that doors were one of the most powerful items to keep raptors away... All those precious moments..
I'm not going to say you're wrong, because you do have your legitimate subjective experience, but it sure wasn't mine.
