I was once downvoted pretty heavily on reddit for answering this question, but my answer is the same:
Physical books
Reading is very important to me, it is an exercise for the brain. If someone does not have a single book in their space, it would cause me to hesitate going on a second date with them. It doesn’t even matter much what genre (with exception to hate filled books), but yeah, have some books on your shelf for me to look at and talk about 😬
Folks who can actively talk about books because they read ebooks or audiobooks get a pass though. At least they read and can discuss, bonus points if they read scifi ☺️