You are entirely correct that I’ve never done an ice bath or a water fast and see no reason or benefit to doing either one. Why should we assume either activity translates to strength training in any meaningful sense? Lets assume that your activities represent mental toughness. Does that translate to knowing how hard you can push yourself during a set? Why would it?
That's fair -- I encourage not just you, but also anyone reading this, to try an ice bath at least once during their lifetime. Fill up their freezer with large water balloons for 3 days. Break off the water balloon and break the ice with a hammer, otherwise the "cooling effect" of the water balloons on the interior of the frozen ice blocks are wasted because only the outer surface is exposed to ambient bath water.
I only began doing ice baths after listening to many people swear by them and due to my curiosity, I must know whether or not they are over-hyped. Most people do not take adhd meds and therefore the biggest benefit (according to some people) is the week long benefit of something to do with a flooding of neurotransmitters -- I'm being intentionally vague because I don't want to explain it incorrectly.
But the biggest benefit I see (and is within the top-3 benefits most people agree on) is that it "resets" your brain's relationship with pain, discomfort, or adversity. That resetting of your brain's relationship with pain, discomfort, or adversity makes you immediately halfway between the person you used to be and the metaphorical David Goggins:
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bklrNzdtU3Q
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPwFimMcoCI
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZtQ8Z--SN4I
I say metaphorical because I don't know if he's legit or a con artist because I don't know him personally. But according to the youtube summary of the final video, ice baths callus your mind as explained below:
- Callus Your Mind (9:55 - 12:07): Regularly seek out intentional discomfort and do the things you hate. This practice uses neuroplasticity to rewire your brain to stay calm and resilient during chaos.