Protesters against an upcoming speaking event with an academic who accused the late Cambridge professor Jason Arday of plagiarism have placed a Ku Klux Klan hood on a controversial statue of the 19th Century colonialist Cecil Rhodes.

Nathan Cofnas, a self-defined "race realist" who argues genes play a "non-trivial role" in intelligence differences between racial groups, is due to speak at an event at Oriel College in Oxford later this month.

Objecting to the event, the campaign group Led By Donkeys placed a white Ku Klux Klan hood and a sign reading "Racists Welcome Here" on the Rhodes statue at Oriel College on Thursday morning.

In response to the protest, the college said it was "committed to upholding freedom of speech within the law and has a statutory duty to do so".

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 12 points 8 hours ago (2 children)

I'm curious how this "statutory duty to freedom of speech" works, considering this is someone spewing racist pseudoscience (if it even reaches the level of pseudoscience). They've also been suspended from academic institutions multiple times. And "may" have caused the suicide of another academic.

Even ignoring the duty of care to students and the "inclusive, welcoming environment" commitment they allege they have... What value is there in debating obviously wrong ideas?

If some professor firmly believed gravity isn't real and the Earth is flat, would that be worth hearing out in an academic context? What value is that to students? "Here's how you debate someone with ingrained ignorance/stupidity"? There are plenty of other ways to do that - use recordings, role play, go out to a (free) event of theirs.

And I've even charitably assumed this is an event where some debate will take place...

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 8 points 7 hours ago

    Quite. "Freedom of speech" refers to government suppression of your speech, and doesn't mean that everyone has to give you a platform for your bullshit. And there's loads of things you can't say anyway. Going into a bank and saying "this is a robbery, give me all your money" isn't you exercising your free speech, it's you robbing the fucking bank.

  • source
  • parent