you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 81 points 1 month ago (8 children)

This is a seriously weak and narrow argument. First off, the parallel drawn with existing tools is shallow. When was the last time an editor or a compiler promised to replace employees? Which of those notably accelerates climate catastrophe? Which one of those is the biggest theft of labor in the history of humanity? Everything is political. Externalizing the social and environmental cost of the major LLMs is taking a clear stance in favour of the late stage capitalistic tech empires currently taking shape.

  • source
  • hideshow 8 child comments
  • [–] 5 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago) (7 children)

    You can't really control the use of tools though, that is the problem. AI detection doesn't work and leads to a lot of false positives. The only thing you can do is check if the product is good.

    AI is horrible for the world but it is impossible to ban it for coding, as you can easily submit AI generated code that looks human.

    He is not comparing the effects that tools have but that you can't control if someone uses them or not.

    The only way I see for controlling the way AI is used, is if the AI companies put restrictions on it.

    If you ban AI, the vibe coders will just lie about the origin of their code.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 7 child comments
  • [+] 9 points 1 month ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago) (4 children)
  • [–] 3 points 1 month ago

    You're correct but still completely missing the point.

    The only way to implement anti-LLM rules is to detect AI-assisted code. That, in and of itself, is a problem because it's impossible to detect good code that was AI assisted. And you don't need rules against slop because it's bad code.

    If I'm following it correctly, Linus is advocating for tightening submission requirements before it gets to human review, which directly targets the harms FOSS projects are having under the deluge of slop: it raises the bar so that the slop needs to be good enough to warrant a review, which filters out must of the noise, leaving more of the signal.

    Anti-LLM policies are like having closed-book take-home exams: you're left wildly guessing what's cheating (or not). Instead, make the exam open book, but expect better answers.

    Linus also says AI is a useful tool, and he is an expert, so we must accept that he feels that way. I don't know if he's commented on the environmental/social/political consequences of AI hyperscalers, but that's a separate argument.

    The tech is here. It's impossible to detect. It's foolish to think you can ban it's use

    And it can be run locally, so there's no stopping it, even if there was political will to do so. (And with a reasonable economic and ecological cost, no less—ignoring IP/political consequences here, since that's a whole other topic.)

  • source
  • parent
  • load more comments (3 replies)
  • load more comments (5 replies)
  • load more comments (5 replies)