cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ca/post/72208315

Russia spent 18 months building its salient toward Sloviansk; Ukraine took much of it back in three. By 30 September, three of four planned phases in, the operation had returned 176 sq km to Ukrainian control, taken 250 Russian prisoners, and cost Russia more than 5,000 killed and wounded, Ukraine's presidential office said. It also foiled a Russian plan to break into the rear of the Sloviansk-Kramatorsk urban area, the office said.

Defying critics who insisted vehicles couldn't possibly survive in the drone-patrolled gray zone, the 3rd Army Corps repeatedly deployed mechanized forces as it counterattacked across a roughly 100 sq km salient the Russian 20th and 25th Combined Arms Armies had extended toward Sloviansk, one of the last two big free cities in Donetsk Oblast.

Maneuvering for months under a veil of secrecy, the 3rd Army Corps found and exploited gaps along the flanks of the 20th and 25th CAAs, ultimately breaking into the Russian armies' rears and forcing them to pull back across the Zherebets River in order to avoid encirclement.

Human Beings in armored vehicles NOT Robots, do you "AI and drones beat everything" techbro armchair generals in the back hear that? Do we need to keep repeating it? Yes? It is called Combined Arms for a reason.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 4 weeks ago

Yes, absolutely,

Ie... the answer is no. Experience is not digital - it is impossible to copy it from one person or organisation to the other. Know-how can be transferred from one person to the other - through instruction and training - but absolutely not experience. This is why there is such a vast difference between combat-trained and combat-experienced.

You are confusing the two. There's an old military saying - the map is not the terrain. And only bitter experience will teach you that it doesn't just apply to geography.

could only mean that war crimes are happening.

I distinctly remember typing this...

That casualty to POW ratio means one of two things - the casualty number is either terrifically inflated or… those mechanised Ukrainian troops have been perpetrating an awful amount of war crimes.

...don't you?

  • source
  • parent