you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 1 month ago

There is some research proving that there are harmful effects in social media, so the proposal is not completely without merits, but I think it negatively affects both teenagers and adults alike.

IMHO they should have banned social media but not social networks. A lot of harm is coming from the algorithmic content pushed on people and social feeds are now 90% ads and shills pushing an agenda, while people are there mostly to "not miss out" the friends' activities.

They could have fixed the problem at the root and tampered the propaganda machine, instead this proposal is likely going to force a terrible implementation of age or identity verification. It might not be too bad if they standardize on some privacy-preserving zero-knowledge-proof solution, but I find that somewhat unlikely.

Another problem with the current proposal is that, if they really wanted to make it age-restricted, a more sensible option would have been to start the ban from a much younger age (I don't know - 5? 8?) increasing it 1 year per year indefinitely, instead of suddenly removing access from people that already have all their friends there. The current implementation will make the EU very unpopular with all the teenagers, and they'll likely still find ways to access it anyway.

  • source