You're arguing the oil ON THE MARKET will cause the end of the human civilization and is a greater threat to us presently and I am arguing oil OFF THE MARKET will cause the end of civilization and is a greater threat to us presently.
I'll give you my top 3 opinions on why OFF THE MARKET is a greater threat:
-Without Oil On The Market we will simply be unable to transition to other forms sustainable energy. This is because sustainable energy needs oil and money in order to be built. An oil shock will cause oil and therefore product supply chain disruption. It will also cause economies to collapse. Leading to money supply issues and less investment on sustainable projects.
-WOOTM we will not be able to maintain quality of life ACROSS THE ENTIRE WORLD. That means individuals already struggling will be pushed to the breaking point/death.
-China is demonstrating how important oil is by utilizing their petroleum reserves to literally KEEP THE WORLD ECONOMY AFLOAT. China understands that without oil there is no world economy and there is no sustainable energy transition. The economy is to be protected from a Marxist point of view! The idea being that if we do anything to hurt the economy we hurt the material conditions of the common man.
Now, in the long term we MUST transition off of oil and into sustainable energy. I agree with you that human civilization is in grave danger. However, the only way we survive the future is by utilizing oil to transition to sustainable energy as China is demonstrating.
I am not pro oil! I am in favor of utilizing it for a more sustainable future which is possible, hopefully!