dfyx comments on Colorado: to test the 911 service, you must first place a normal call to the 911 center. WTF, they don’t think you might be unable to make normal calls (the very reason you need to test 911)?

Colorado: to test the 911 service, you must first place a normal call to the 911 center. WTF, they don’t think you might be unable to make normal calls (the very reason you need to test 911)? (puc.colorado.gov)

submitted 2 months ago by debanqued@beehaw.org to c/technology@beehaw.org

locked 17 comments fedilink hide all child comments

From the linked FAQ:

How can I make a test 9-1-1 call? To make a test 9-1-1 call, you need to first contact the 9-1-1 center that serves your area. The non-emergency numbers for Colorado's 9-1-1 centers are available here(opens in new window). If you're unsure which 9-1-1 center serves your area, call the 911 Program at 303-894-2871, and we'll help you identify the 9-1-1 center for the location you want to test from.

When you call the 9-1-1 center, ask them if it would be okay to make a test 9-1-1 call. If they are particularly busy or are handling a major incident, they may ask you to call back at a later time.

When your phone cannot make normal calls for whatever reason¹, you obviously want to know if 911 calls will at least work. And the idiots design a test procedure that requires normal phone calls to work.

① Typical reasons why you may be unable to make normal calls:

You have a GSM phone with no GSM chip, or unsubscribed chip.
You are on a prepaid plan and have no credit.

So indeed the telecom industry has a glaring competency problem.

[–] dfyx@lemmy.helios42.de 10 points 2 months ago* (4 children)

You're constructing an argument that's so specific, you're basically begging to be the victim.

If you a) have a device that can't make regular calls b) have no way to contact a non-emergency number through a different device to ask if it's okay to make a test call and c) absolutely need to test this right now, then you're about one in a million. Just make that call, answer the "what's your emergency?" question with "No emergency right now, I need to test that my device that can't make regular calls will work in a real emergency. Sorry, I couldn't reach your non-emergency number." and it will be fine.

It's only an illegit 911 call if you call them for fun or if you test so often it can no longer be considered necessary.

permalink

fedilink

source

parent

hideshow 4 child comments

[–] debanqued@beehaw.org [S] -5 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago) (3 children)

and it will be fine.

Citation needed that there will be no fine to pay. Why not do a bit of research before making such claims? Quick search for false 911 call should flood your search results with fines, like $316 in Los Angeles.

South Carolina: misdemeanor. The penalties can include up to six months in jail, a fine of up to $200, or both.

It’s only an illegit 911 call if you call them for fun or if you test so often it can no longer be considered necessary.

Citation needed.

When attackers notice their victim making a distress call, they obviously convince them to back off and say the call was an accident. Emergency dispatchers will send help anyway to ensure coersion is not the case.

permalink

fedilink

source

parent

hideshow 3 child comments

[–] dfyx@lemmy.helios42.de 8 points 2 months ago* (2 children)

Well, go ask the non-emergency line if it's okay. That's what is recommended. Looks like you have access to the internet. What keeps you from writing an email to your local police station and just asking what you should do? I can't know where you live. I can only tell you that in my 38 years of life, these things have been solved by actually talking to people or trying things. Certainly not by complaining on the internet to people who can't do anything about it and then not even suggesting a better solution.

Sorry, but you don't seem like you want a solution. You want something to complain about.

permalink

fedilink

source

parent

hideshow 2 child comments

[+] debanqued@beehaw.org [S] -1 points 2 months ago (2 children)

[removed by mod]

permalink

fedilink

source

parent

hideshow 2 child comments

[–] dfyx@lemmy.helios42.de 6 points 2 months ago* (1 child)

Some of us are activists. It is our duty expose incompetence.

It is nobody's duty to expose anything for the sake of exposing it. It is our duty to expose things for the sake of solving them. If you have a better solution, we're ready to hear it.

The question is, why would have it covered up?

I don't see anything being covered up. You have linked an official government website that tells you how to perform the test. Looks like you have found it. Doesn't seem like much of a secret. Where else should they put it?

Of course the reason I was looking into how to test 911 is because I actually fucking need to test it

Then do what they tell you to do: contact them beforehand (borrow a phone from a neighbor or send them an email) and ask if they have free capacity for a test call and what you should do if you don't know which 911 call center your VOIP setup will reach.

you asshole!

Reported.

permalink

fedilink

source

parent

hideshow 1 child comment

[–] debanqued@beehaw.org [S] -1 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

It is nobody’s duty to expose anything for the sake of exposing it.

Bullshit. Exposure is the 1st step.

It is our duty to expose things for the sake of solving them.

Of course. But not necessarily directly. There are many ways to solve a problem. Spotlighting an embarrassment is a precursor. You can also travel to a call center and apply to work for them to improve their system. You do you.

If you have a better solution, we’re ready to hear it.

It’s not my problem to solve. Do you also demand that testers fix the bugs they report?

You’re perversely out of step with how volunteer effort is managed. Volunteers choose for themselves how much effort they contribute. You are not their manager. It’s not for you to drive-by task people and bark out orders. When a bug is reported, it’s public for anyone to solve, if they want. It’s a community. Not a corporation.

I don’t see anything being covered up.

You don’t know how threadcrap works. It’s designed to suppress the thesis by creating a distraction.