I'm thinking of giving Soulstice a go , partly because I was reminded I already have it when looking at the humble bundles (the one it was in just expired yesterday). It looks a little jank, but pretty alright.
I agree with your sentiment about DS1 and I think it hasn't aged as well as the others (which is why it deserves a remake, ahem Bed of Chaos), but I would probably choose Fromsoft's game METAL WOLF CHAOS XD because it looks like a bad Armored Core (I'd still try it though).