Well usually I find people like answers to their questions, and am generally happy to help when I have those answers. It can also be interesting to run through the hypothetical scenario this sort of response would suggest. However, just because we can and did put the scenario in a framework of logic and see what that gave us, that doesn't mean the original scenario is meant for it. Calling it illogical nonsense when it was never meant to be a genuine scenario is like calling a fish a horrible distance runner. You're not wrong, but you're missing the entire point.