It would need to be significantly cheaper than lead acid to offset all those disadvantages. With lead acid, it's ready to go immediately in an emergency, you get 500 recharges, and lasts for 5 years.
But lithium iron phosphate is the real leader. Cheap, lightweight, 10-20 year lifespan, thousands of recharges.
Both lead acid and lithium iron are completely recyclable. Lead acid batteries have an established recovery and recycling system at 99% compared to 50% for aluminum recycling.