It seems like you are missing the point of what the other user was trying to say.
So I'll give you my post answer here instead, since it fits just as well:
It Depends On Each Situation.
I might lean more towards a big picture person for some issues but more towards details first for other issues. My current state (health, fatigue, emotions) can also influence these so that I would lean more towards one end of your spectrum in a certain situation but then I might lean towards the other end in the same situation but, say, I'm now not fatigued or maybe I'm starving.
It depends.