I have seen some critical views on Nostr as a part of decentralized network discussions, but most seem to be focused on culture not function.

What are the functional / protocol differences that make you prefer ActivityPub over Nostr?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 17 points 11 months ago (5 children)

I don't know much about recent developments, but the early version of the protocol had several major flaws:- Identity is based on a non-rotatable key, other types of identity are not supported.- No privacy without encryption.- Media attachments are not supported, all images are stored on a single server.- Servers only store data and don't do anything else, so they get abstracted away and everyone uses the same 5 relays (in Fediverse each server has a personality, and that creates a strong incentive to self-host).There are also many minor things that I dislike, for example the use of numbers instead of human-readable names, unusual cryptography and so on.

  • source
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 11 months ago

    As of more recently:

    • The identity system is still the same, keys aren't rotatable and still the core of your account. Outside of edge cases like Frost Bunkers (outsourcing key management to a cluster of third party servers), or platforms like DiVine letting you register with an email, keys remain pretty much the same.
    • Private infomration like DMs have been altered. They're still E2E encrypted, but now only the people involved in the conversation can request a copy of the encrypted DM (I assume that's what you're referring to, but I may be mistaken).
    • Media attachements are usually uploaded to Blossom servers now. Standard notes still only embed remote media, but the ecosystem has a semi decentralized means of hosting content, and most clients will have a more standard 'upload and share' type of feature that most other platforms/protocols have.
    • The more recent outbox model (on supported clients) allows you to set the relays that will host your content and replies/reactions to your content, diversifying the ecosystem away from a handful of big relays. Software like Ditto also provides a more Mastodon community style experience - even to the extent of supporting the Mastodon API.
  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 11 months ago (2 children)

    of numbers instead of human-readable names

    TBF, they have introduced a 'verified' system that lets you use human readable names.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments