you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 5 points 1 year ago (3 children)

my brother in christ, you mean the one where he acts like a homophobic fascist? and said he joined the fascist corps because he wanted to kill people?

Can you point me to those comments? I've looked at his comment history yes. Maybe I missed these parts. It's pretty large so obviously everyone's going to pick their favorite part to present, but what I saw was him calling himself a communist, yelling at people who were excusing war crimes and talking about some of the fucked up stuff he saw in the military and how it radicalized him.

look into the comments he made himself about abu ghraib.

Which comments were those?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 1 year ago (2 children)

    Nah I don't like authoritarian simpers either but Platner is pretty sus

    Just 5 years ago he said he joined the marines because he:

    Wanted to have an adventure and kill some people. Joined up in ‘04, did Fallujah and Ramadi, and managed both. Hell of an excellent experience.

    Also he did definitely serve as a prison guard in Abu Ghraib and took part in suppressing people trying to liberate others from being imprisoned and tortured:

    Later, while he was on patrol at Abu Ghraib, there was an attack on the prison. (It was nearly two years after human-rights abuses were first reported at the prison; Platner was not involved.) “That was my first real taste of combat,” he said.

    Also he was calling everything bad "gay" and used "fags" as an insult as late as 2021 (oddly seems a bit closeted tbh but w/e)

    And look it's not like the Mothership PAC lover Jordan Woods will fight the oligarchy so this kinda leaves Janet Mills who isn't ideal but idk at least she didn't rejoice in killing brown people 🤷

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago

    Okay, I do appreciate the actual sourcing. Now that we're looking into it, it doesn't say what you said it says.

    It says, "On patrol at Abu Ghraib." Abu Ghraib is a place as well as a prison. Was inside the prison, on patrol as a guard? Or outside it, on patrol as an infantryman in the place called Abu Ghraib? There is not enough from that single sentence to tell which of those it is. Why do you say that one sentence proves that he was a prison guard at Abu Ghraib? Why are the people freaking out about what a massive deal it is that he had a tattoo or other random character-assassination bullshit haven'd said anything other than that one sentence, about him being a full-on guard at Abu Ghraib and then never having said a word about it or any of the abuses he saw there?

    It could be that second thing. I'm just saying that just that one sentence doesn't mean to me that he was a prison guard there. There's a careful ambiguity about "on patrol at Abu Ghraib" and no followup.

    Also he was calling everything bad "gay" and used "fags" as an insult as late as 2021 (oddly seems a bit closeted tbh but w/e)

    He wasn't using "fags" as an insult in 2021, he was saying in 2021, “I like how our gay antics make him so uncomfortable he hates us. I’m doubling down on gay chicken next time in honor of this Air Force pussy.”

    He also said:

    He attributed his change in perspective to friendships with LGBTQ+ people, both gay and transgender, that deepened after he returned to Maine. “When I lived in Washington, D.C., I had a number of very close gay friends,” Platner said, with whom he often “attended showtunes night at JR’s,” a popular gay bar near Dupont Circle. “It was only later, when I moved back to Maine, that I became friends with a number of trans people, and that really opened my eyes.”

    “Even though I thought I was open-minded,” he continued, “there were elements to their existence that I had been entirely unaware of. That was when I began to really take far more seriously the damaging nature of language, the damaging nature of even just discussing whether people exist or not.”

    He said that realization led him to speak publicly in defense of LGBTQ+ students. “Earlier this year, I testified at a local school board meeting in defense of a policy that was protecting LGBTQ students,” he said. “For me, at this point in my life, you either stand for what you stand for or you don’t.”

  • source
  • parent