you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 18 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago) (2 children)

Jesus Christ I'm so tired of this shit. "What if climate change is actually good because you can grow food in colder climates? Then we wouldn't have to change anything, which I really don't want to anyway." "What if masks actually make you more likely to contract COVID? Then I wouldn't have to wear one, which I really don't want to anyway." And now, "What if exposing yourself to radiation is actually good for you?"

This is absolute nonsense. The Wikipedia article is full of "[unreliable source?]" and "highly controversial," and the video starts out with stuff like, "Actually, all the experts agree with me, they're just afraid of speaking up," which instantly destroyed any willingness to suspend my disbelief on this nonsense.

Yes, there is a tiny amount of radiation in a banana that isn't enough to cause harm. But that has absolutely nothing to do with nuclear reactors. The difference between "harmless" and "extremely lethal" with radiation can change drastically depending on factors like distance, in ways that are not intuitive to most people. Treating radioactive material and radiation produced by a reactor with extreme caution is the best practice regardless, because if things go wrong, they can go very, very wrong. You cannot mishandle a banana in such a way that it destroys a city, which is a something I never thought I would have to explain.

Furthermore, your dismissal of other forms of green energy is outdated, it may have been true 20-30 years ago but the technology has advanced and will keep advancing and with the massive upfront cost of reactors it doesn't usually make sense to build new ones (although keeping existing ones running is often reasonable imo).

If you're gonna push this then at least present actual evidence.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 1 year ago

    The up front cost of nuclear is largely all the red tape caused by fear mongering.

    Which is wild because coal plants release more radiation per kW generated than nuclear.

    Renewable tech has gotten far better in even the last 5 years.

    It won't ever be able to handle 24/7/365 base loads, but they've already proven far more robust in developing places like Texas that cannot keep their fossil fuel plants running reliably in inclement weather.

    Jokes aside, seriously, the answer is, and always will be nuclear + renewables.

  • source
  • parent
  • load more comments (1 reply)