To punish the guilty more harshly without hurting the innocent would require
- That the justice system makes no mistakes
- That the justice system is not corrupt
- That the justice system is not influenced by politics/money/power
"Oh it's just the actual predators" "it's just the criminal illegals" "it's just used against terrorist"
No it's never "just" X.
The justice system is made up of people. People make mistakes. People have opinions. Some people are corrupt. People can be fooled. People can be influenced.
This is why it's important to have principles and just laws and basic human rights for everyone.
You see an "actual predator", perhaps it's just a person framed for political beliefs. It's better just to treat everyone fairly. Fair trials and a way to fight unfair sentences.