[–] 2 points 1 year ago

based on my anecdotal experience your comment sounds rather biased.

That's called an opinion. Usually, you can identify those when someone writes something like "I don't like it"

Godot's easy to use, that's its strength. Past that, it is riddled with issues. A lot of APIs are either poorly designed, half-implemented, or outright broken. The engine has terrible extensibility support due to a shitty build system, which is why you need to download a separate build of the engine if you want C# support. Third party native plugins like Spine also require a custom build of the engine to deal with this (want to use multiple third party "plugins"? Start learning C++ and scons so you can glue them together yourself). The internal organization of the code is sloppy, and while understandable due to it initially being a one-man project, the situation has not improved despite the massive increase in volunteers and money it has had over the years. There's a lot of bike shedding that goes on, and leadership doesn't seem to have a clear vision of where to take the engine.

GDScript sucks. The events system sucks. The hierarchical entity design sucks (although the nestable scenes helps smooth that over). Godot physics sucks. Jolt physics is better, but the integration sucks (Try making joints. The only reliable one is the 6DOF joint, but that requires you to fiddle with dozens of parameters to try and achieve what you want). A lot of the rendering features suck and/or are broken, even basic things like static lighting and shadowmaps fall apart with basic geometry. Everything is buggy as hell, and that's something you just need to accept if you're going to make games with it.

I don't hate Godot, and I do use it because of its main strength: ease of use. It's my go-to for game jams and prototyping, and I have used it a lot. But if I'm going to invest serious time/effort into a project, I'm not going to disadvantage myself right out the gate by choosing Godot.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 1 year ago (5 children)
    • HaxeFlixel is a popular choice for 2D stuff. You can use it with Tiled or LDTK for level editing. This sounds more like what you're looking for

    • Defold might interest you as it has a full editor built in, though I've barely used it so don't ask if it's good

    • Gamemaker is a classic, but idk what pricing is like nowadays

    • Godot will work, but I don't like it. Once you get past the highly polished editor, everything else kinda sucks

  • source
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›