you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 40 points 13 hours ago (5 children)

So then... why weren't they selling them for dirt cheap?

Oh yeah because "supply and demand" isn't a science like they want you to believe, it's just a tool they use to rationalize their exploitation of working class consumers and a compass to guide their market manipulation.

  • source
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 14 points 12 hours ago (2 children)

    Supply and demand is a science, and it's that predictability that enables entities with large capital access to artificially limit supply to enforce market conditions preferential to them. (De beers).

    The free market is an idealised model which requires physically impossible assumptions to function. Regulation and approximations are what are required to ensure that the free market will tend towards balanced supply and demand instead of over-sized entities (monopolies and oligopolies) to exercise outsized market control. A slightly imperfect free market is still great, a grossly imperfect one is barely different from feudalism.

    In other words, we have anti-monopoly regulations for a reason. The problem arises when those with the power to control the entities with outsized influence are instead bought by them.

    (I am absolutely not pro free market btw, but it is a valid model for human behaviour when its assumptions are close enough to be approximated)

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 7 points 12 hours ago

    You have some good points, but I disagree that supply and demand is a science. I think the evidence is abundant that it's merely a social construct and only behaves somewhat according to its own theory because enough people believe in its reality for it to be self-perpetuating. A sufficient change in paradigm could reveal a very different dynamic.

    As for free-markets, I believe a large part of the issues we're seeing today can be traced back to the confusion/conflation of "free markets" with "capitalism."

    Free markets have existed for as long as humans have been bartering. They existed in the ancient Greek agoras, along the Silk road, and pretty much anywhere archeologists have discovered some form of currency or trade.

    Capitalism is an early-modern invention based on the ownership and transfer of capital; i.e. trading of stocks or shares in the ownership of a company, which then hires executives, administrators, managers, etc., all delegated to perform their functions within a daisy chain of middlemen, all with the purpose of extracting as much profit as possible from the resources of the environment and the laborers who actually produce the value.

    It's completely different from free market. Capitalism can (and does currently) exist without a free market. Free markets likewise can exist (and have existed) without capitalism.

    You can have free markets in a socialistic economy. The only difference is the workers own the means of production, which can take the form of employee-owned co-ops governed by democratic labor unions. That and the purpose of the economy isn't to extract profit for the benefit of capital, but rather to provide for the needs of society.

    Food, water, utilities, housing, clothes, safety, healthcare, education, etc., these are all necessary things in society that take some participation of its members to provide. But there's no reason why any of that needs to be provided for the sole purpose of extracting profits. That's just the current economic system we live in.

    Comfort items, leisure activity equipment, recreational and creative endeavors, etc., aren't exactly necessities as particulars (i.e., nobody needs a set of golf clubs), but as a category, these things are a social need, as society needs to provide the option of exploring such things if it wants to be considered a free, fair, just, equitable, and thriving/flourishing society.

    And a free market is a decent system for providing those options, because (for example) if there's demand for art supplies, somebody will make a livelihood providing those things. But as soon as it becomes about producing profit for shareholders (i.e. capital) then it becomes soulless, toxic, and destructive.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 5 points 8 hours ago (1 child)

    "supply and demand” isn’t a science

    It's a relationship uses to describe how one affects the other. It's like Force = Mass × Acceleration. It's not technically a science, but it can be used to make predictions based on observations, which can have some scientific applications.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 3 hours ago

    Yes but the relationship isn't as fixed and immutable as Force = Mass × Acceleration, or Watts = Volts × Amps.

    That's what I mean by it isn't a science. A soft science at best, but more like a pseudoscience.

    There are so many other factors that go into pricing than simply Supply & Demand. Much more significant in our economy is the whim of the supplier and the degree to which they've either captured the market or colluded with their so-called competitors, and the neverending obsession with "line go up."

    Necessity is another such factor. Insulin is easy to produce. There's no shortage of it. But they charge you out the ass for it because if you don't pay it, you die. That's different from demand, because demand is about how much is needed (quantity), whereas necessity is about how badly it's needed.

    So in practice "supply and demand" is often used to hand-wave or explain away things like excessive inflation (more accurately greedflation), when the reality is these corporations are making record profits. Because this isn't about relative abundance of goods, this is about deliberate price gouging.

    Which, along with enshittification and stagnating wages, is a completely predictable consequence of an economic philosophy which claims infinite growth is both possible and desirable. And our entire economic system is built upon the compulsion towards infinite growth.

  • source
  • parent