you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 19 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago)

this is a beta release and will NOT be pushed to the repository

Yeah, that's a nono from me. That's a big security red flag.

Secondly, if goes against the stated goal of having testers find bugs. Part of finding bugs is being able to go through the code and figure out what issues are happening, in what parts of the code.

Finally, this project appears vibecoded. Here is the initial commit: https://github.com/adityakrishnan005-a11y/ScreenGuard/commit/c97cc2e6bd17b35e99ff0bb892aeed41f95cb4e0

That's a lot of code in the initial commit. And emojis in the .md's...

There are also some other bad patterns like binaries in the git repo :/

I can see why this project received mixed review on it's previous pass. Please:

  • Transparency about LLM usage — Allow people to make informed decisions rather than concealing it. You are still going to get mixed reviews, but it's better to be honest
  • No more binaries in the repo. C'mon
  • All code has to be public. It's not actually open source if not all code is public.

It's a cool project, sure.

But what makes this project better than something I could vibecode? What makes this project better than the previously existing https://github.com/polesapart/timekpr-next , or other time keeper/time control projects? Can you guarantee that this project will stay maintained, which is a common issue with vibecoded projects.

  • source