fundamental problems around Matrix
Sorry, this list just re-hashes the usual talking points and cranks the nerdery to 11. "Reliance on JSON" is just an stupid of an argument as criticizing XMPP for using XML. Saying "the main client uses Electron", presenting it like it is the only alternative (it's not), focusing on a completely secondary platform (pretty much everyone wants to use a messenger on mobile, so why does it matter to have an optimized client on the desktop?) makes this whole thing seem like it was written by a teenager arguing over racing cars.
in theory the iOS XMPP app experience can be improved relatively easily
Then why isn't it?! Why is it that the "recommended" client for iOS looks like something from 2005?