A few days ago I came across a comment in one of this Instance's Communities made by a user of this Instance, which very directly parroted Nazi talking points. Not in a way that was satirising Nazis, but which was endorsing their type of supremacist worldview.

Other comments in that thread noted that the user in question has a history of unironically endorsing a foreign genocidal regime and its actions.

I tried reporting the comment in question, but as of today the comment still stands and the user who made the comment has been as active as ever.

Is this Instance ok with Nazis?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 14 points 8 months ago (29 children)

We're missing a bit of information here. I got your report, went to the thread to get the context.

Firstly, I saw that you had literally screen-capped the comment in question and included it in a new reply. So, removing the comment would have achieved nothing - it would have still been there.
Secondly, the comment was Zionistic in nature, which while especially unpopular in nature is not against instance rules.
Thirdly, I wasn't aware that the comment in question was similar to something Nazis said. I don't even know if the user who made the comment knew that. So, leaving it there and letting downvotes do their thing allowed for education as well.
Lastly, the comment was in the Australian Politics community - which is intentionally the lightest-touch moderated community because there's a difference between political discussion where parties disagree quite vehemently and an outright echo-chamber. If you delete all the users from your politics community that you don't agree with, what is the point of the community?

To answer your question: No, we don't allow Nazis here. It is literally one of the questions we ask on the application screen. "Nazi talking points" is not on its own a good metric of what is acceptable today. We basically have a whole community in support of Reichsnaturschutzgesetz. I don't especially take issue with Tierschutz, either. One of the reasons the Third Reich gained actual popular support was some of their early policies were in fact in the best interest of the German people. There is still a Kindergeld today, though giving full credit to the Nazis to that one wouldn't really be genuine. It is fair to say they supported this policy. So I guess our stance on "literal Nazi talking points" will boil down to other factors and get taken on a case-by-case basis.

Finally: If there's a user you genuinely don't wish to see around here any longer, you can hit the little down arrow on any of their comments and block them.

  • source
  • hideshow 29 child comments
  • [–] 18 points 8 months ago (11 children)

    I want to raise a point on the "Nazi talking points" response:

    • On one hand, it's certainly more useful when a report is more specific, yes. I know plenty of fascist talking points which aren't common knowledge or obvious.
    • On the other, it sounds like they're talking about Lebensraum - "living space". If we look at it technically, it was a common concept in German politics decades before the Nazi Party was formed. And it's a far cry away from the various social reforms implemented in the Third Reich you mentioned. But in context, I think it's clear that someone on aussie.zone reporting a post for "Nazi talking points" is reporting that a post is fascistic, supporting the supremacist aspects Nazism is famous for. People surely aren't going to report pro-vegetarian posts for this reason, or even anti-union posts (despite the crushing of worker's organisations being core to fascism).

    Lebensraum is a relatively infamous policy, and one which neo-Nazis like the NSN explicitly invoke. They're never holding up banners saying "protect the wildlife", "support animal rights" or "fast roadways now!", this is the bigoted supremacy generally associated with Nazism and carried on by neo-Nazism.

    If you delete all the users from your politics community that you don’t agree with, what is the point of the community?

    But this isn't just "all the users you disagree with", or even just disagreement - if someone, when discussing an expansionist regime, tries to justify "living space", that makes me think that person might well want me thrown in a camp and killed. It's no smoking gun, but it's a loud wolfwhistle.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 11 child comments
  • [–] 11 points 8 months ago (10 children)

    Lebensraum is a relatively infamous policy, and one which neo-Nazis like the NSN explicitly invoke.

    Sorry. While I readily acknowledge that I don't hang out in those circles, nor really scrutinise their rhetoric, I have honestly never heard that phrase before. In English or German. This does paint the comment in a brighter light, and I probably would have been more inclined to remove it had I been familiar with the term.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [–] 6 points 8 months ago

    Yep, exactly, and that's why I say it's more useful when a report is more specific - most people are lucky enough that they aren't exposed to online neo-Nazism enough to know their rhetoric, euphemisms, codes and symbols (beyond the swastika).

  • source
  • parent
  • load more comments (9 replies)
  • load more comments (9 replies)
  • load more comments (26 replies)